Once JA2 was one of my favourite games. A genre defining classic.
The personalities of the mercs are unforgettable and the personality mechanic has not been matched by any other game to date.
The rpg mechanics and the funny details are still great.
But after playing Battle Brothers I can no more recommend this game for the tactical gameplay.
The chance to hit calculation is obscure, how the line of sight works, how aiming is affected by all circumstances (like cover, stance, weapon condition, skills, mood...)
Fighting alongside the militia is boring since the militia a.i. takes very long and is often running back and forth.
The interrupt mechanic combined with enemies camping leading to frustration.
The game is also very weapon drop dependent.
As a result the game feels more like a game of luck than a tactical game.
Even a simplified XCom is more tactical.
JA2 also does not run flawless on win10 even with the stratiatella patch.
Battle Brothers fails on the strategic part and as an RPG but has a superior tactical gameplay.