Not at all a Gothic game. Don't get confused by the name and visuals. Bends the story of Gothic, makes your favorite characters unlikable. This abomination shouldn't be here and especially should not be sold by Piranha Bytes themselves!
Satisfying shooting action, has its own style and fiction, good storytelling, scary only in the beginning but doesn't get old. Would definitely recommend to buy if if the money did not go to EA.
These games belong to the list of the top classics: QFG 1-4, Lands of Lore 1, King's Quest 6, Legend of Kyrandia 1, Full Throttle, Simon the Sorcerer 1 & 2, Warcraft 2 & Death Gate.