I'd give this game 4.75 out of 5 stars. Why the - .25? Because a couple of the NPCs got on my nerves a bit which is purely personal taste - they might not bother you at all - or you might even love them. And a couple of the jokes went on longer than I felt was necessary - again personal taste. Other than that. It was everything I hoped for and more. Loved the setting (with extra points for Delores' room) the story line, the puzzles, the interface, the navigation, and the freedom to try whatever I wanted whenever I wanted without worrying about being unceremoniously killed. Highly recommended.