Posted on: February 20, 2018

TedMosly

Jeux: 124 Avis: 9

Good RPG

PoE start slow and can come to boredom after a short time... But, when Act II is reached, history becomes more profound and interesting... like a cup of milk with honey, when you approach the bottom of the cup, the milk becomes increasingly sweet. PRO: - Lore and story. - Level Design of the dungeons. - Many factions and varieties of enemies. - Many moral choices for characters dialogues. - Excellent Art Design. - Violent and outspoken (not politically correct). VERSUS: - Fantasy setting is too classic and "trivial". - Too many loadings. - Just a few really funny characters. - Casting spells is limited by rest - Poor dubbing of the characters. - Poor loot variety from enemies. - Anonymous musics 7.8/10

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: November 19, 2017

oddious

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 53 Avis: 1

Three times good!

I'm quite a casual player and do not prefer any particular genre but rather look for an interesting game to immerse into. I do not need a powerful computer as gaming is not my priority and modern games require to invest a lot into hardware. So I occasionally turned to GOG to taste a few 10-15 years old games that I missed back in the 2000s. The most memorable RPGs I played in those times were the Fallout and Diablo series, which I all walked through, perhaps even a couple of times. The Infinity engine games I, oddly enough, discovered only recently through GOG. Planescape Torment impressed me by its unprecedentedly deep story and then I turned to Baldur's Gate to be impressed by its full D&D game mechanics. Yet I didn't manage to walk through them as at some point I became bothered. They might have been perfect games 15 years ago for a younger person but now it seemed ridiculous to spend so much time on repeating things like carrying the equipment back and forth, resting after every fight to recover health and a few other things. And now here is Pillars of Eternity. I carefully read through a couple of dozens of reviews and while those on the first page give the game 5 stars and excited vows, many of those on the following pages rate it quite poorly. I nevertheless decided to give it a try. And I'm more than impressed. It's sleek, polished, beautiful, interesting, and what is more important, it is a game! It is not a business-merchendsing-advertising noname product in a beautiful wrapping almost empty inside aimed to be sold to you by all means. It is solidly a piece of game art, e.g. the art of creating games, personally I would even say it is a masterpiece. The company behind the game did a great job both in sticking to spirit and traditions of classics, and showing their own creativeness and mature vision. I did not describe the game's mechanics or storytelling, this has been done much better by other reviewers. My point is that if you are a 30+ person with casual gaming habits and a bit of nostalgia for good old games, this is the best isometric RPG to be played in 2017-- I have found so far.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: November 3, 2019

adrieux

Jeux: 420 Avis: 165

Le successeur de Baldur's Gate

Un gameplay old school et une interface rappelant son père spirituel, comme promis dans la campagne Kickstarter. Des graphismes sublimes qui prouvent que beauté ne rime pas forcément avec 3D. Un système de règles bien plus efficace que cet immonde D&D (avis perso, que les rôlistes puristes ne prennent pas la mouche). Des éléments de gameplay qui manquaient cruellement à Baldur : gestion de la réputation, gestion d'un fort, système d'alignement amélioré, scènes scriptées textuelles habilement rendues. Un scénario qui dépasse largement l'aspect si manichéen des Royaumes Oubliés. Une écrite parfaite, si on omet la traduction française parfois hasardeuse. Bref, le pied. Dommage toutefois que les combats soient parfois brouillés, la faute à des effets spéciaux un peu trop bordéliques. Et quelle idée saugrenue d'avoir mis un niveau d'XP maximal qu'on atteint avant le dernier acte ? Un héritage de Baldur dont on se serait passé.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: February 27, 2021

TEHtwitcher

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 244 Avis: 4

Pillars of boredom

Sorry but after many hours I'm about to give up because I'm bored to tears by the writing and game design. The Character writing is just so bland, and I really become immersed or connect with any of my party. The pathfinding AI is absolutely terrible and depite tinkering I can't stop melee characters engaging the nearest enemy, no matter which enemy I target at the onset of combat. I don't get the levelling system either because you're mostlly bound by class and effectively locked out dialouge options because you didn't build a very high perception character and dialogue skill checks are 85% perception, but then if you don't have will/fortitude you'll be forver charmed /petrified /stunned in combat by evey bloody creature with the ability. Levelling... Oh great! I'm stuck with my original build and can only pick perks. Are all RPG's now being reduced to perks instead of stat points or do I have to restart and grind through for the stats my character need? I get that there's classes and it's not Skyrim where you can have it all but not being able to tailor my character base stats as I go is really taking away some of the fun in an RPG. As of 2021 there aren;t too many Obsidian bugs (so far) but the game still has a habit of long load times for small maps and abymal low frame rate stuttering that requires you to tab out and in a few times to fix. I's not the smoothest under 'normal' function, even with custom water loop cooled 3800x, 2080Ti and 16Gb 3600MHz cl15 RAM on a Samsung 1tb Evo ssd. All things considered it's not a truly bad game, just a few design choices and a feeling of "That'll do, push it out the door" hold it back from being a solid, if uninspiring game. As it is I'd give it a solid "Meh" out of 10. Tyranny did it all so much better...

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: September 19, 2025

Louard_le_Barbare

Jeux: 294 Avis: 124

A game good enough to revive its genre

Pillars of Eternity is basically a modern translation of the Baldur's Gate series and its Infinity Engine derivatives, clearly emulating their unique brand of real-time action, isometric exploration, deep storytelling and painted graphics... And well, pretty much each of these aspects is nailed. It's an enthralling adventure with unique characters and exciting combat, set in eye-popping environments - seriously, the beauty of prerendered visuals should not be underestimated! But while it is clearly inspired by classic CRPGs (and DnD in general), it's far from a nostalgia bait ripoff. The character building system is complex, offering a staggering number of spells and combat maneuvers to master. And as expected from Obsidian, PoE's writing is consistently highbrow, almost poetic at times; the worldbuilding rises above your average "dwarves and elves" MedFan setting with its detailed lore and magical peculiarities. You will be showered with questlines featuring memorable characters and exploring bold, esoteric themes... Many of which will force you to take complicated moral decisions! But PoE isn't free from issues, some inherited from its inspirations: like for the BG series the lousy AI often makes it feel like you're babysitting a bunch of brain-damaged kids through the chaos of the real-time combat. While most of the fights are unchallenging, this becomes an actual problem whenever you stumble upon one of the campaign's sudden difficulty spikes. Plus as often with Obsidian games, the decisions you make fuel somewhat obtuse approval systems that can lead to disappointing endings for some story arcs. In the end PoE is a fine game, and a big, beautiful, generous adventure that will satisfy your retro CRPG cravings. That being said, as good as it is I don't think it stands out that much either, and I get why part of its target audience found it disappointing; the genre has indeed better or more significant works that I'd recommend prioritizing over this one.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Découvrez les jeux de CD PROJEKT RED

Ne manquez pas

Featured

Proche, mais pas une correspondance exacte

Pillars of Eternity: Hero Edition

Autres notes

Ajouter un avis

Modifier un avis

Supprimer cet avis ?

Signaler cet avis

Informations complémentaires (obligatoire) :

Signaler cet avis