It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Dear Miss Manners;

I tend to spell it with two "g"s, a la "Gogger". Am I violating some unwritten etiquette?
avatar
TheJoe: It is Goger and nothing else.

Reason is GOG-er rather than GO-ger.

It makes it Good Old Gamer, so it's essentially a blended acronym.

Essentially, you blend the noun GOG with er. It makes no sense to blend it with ger.
But don't you run into etymological difficulties with that? For if your classic game about frogs is Frogger, then surely you will find that you need to follow the same format for the double G in Gogger?

An an aside, any day when I get to use "etymological" in a sentence can be wholly bad. :P
avatar
trevor.longino: But don't you run into etymological difficulties with that? For if your classic game about frogs is Frogger, then surely you will find that you need to follow the same format for the double G in Gogger?
avatar
pops117: But since GOG is an acronym and Frog isn't, I think (Foolish Repulsive Old Gentlemen) we can get away with it just fine.

avatar
trevor.longino: An an aside, any day when I get to use "etymological" in a sentence can be wholly bad. :P
avatar
pops117: Bad for whom I may ask? :O
That should be can't, but my typing skills get worse and worse the closer it gets to midnight. Once we're past 11.30 or local time, I pretty much just mush my face against the keyboard and then hit "submit" eventually.
avatar
pops117: Pretty impressive actually if your typed that with your head.
567zu8ip ßu}7uj <- the best I manage to do :/

GOG did well when getting you on board :D
My prehensile eyebrows were of particular interest to the interviewing team. ;)
avatar
TheJoe: I think we run into more etymological difficulties by using Gogger. There's a G in there that simply comes from nowhere, creating an inconsistency between the title of the site and the title of its members.

It's simply because GOG is an acronym/abbreviation rather than a proper noun, so it makes more sense to simply add the "er" inflection after the noun. Much like "AFKer" or "FOFOer" (an acronym we use in out-of-classroom assignments in college).

Essentially, Gogers GOG, where GOG becomes a verb.

(As a further aside, this isn't really etymology, it's more morphology)
It really is more morphology than etymology, yes. I guess my question is, given how English treats a glottal stop after an open vowel, wouldn't Goger tend to be pronounced like "Kroger" or "doge"--that is, with a soft "g"--rather than with the hard glottal stop that we'd assume is customary, from GOG?

I guess it comes down to: has GOG gone far enough on its way to world domination that we can assume that GOG no longer stands for anything as an acronym, but is merely a monolithic presence? Is it, like a laser, an acronym whose acronymity has transcended into a unique word of its own, or do we treat it, still, as a linguistic shorthand?

...I suspect I'm putting way too much thought into this.
Post edited December 07, 2010 by trevor.longino