Posted on: July 29, 2022

Tragically_Comedic
Verified ownerGames: 192 Reviews: 1
Awful game propped up by toxic fans
I've had this game on Steam and then on here almost since it first came out. Even after the "enhanced" edition came out that allegedly fixed a ton of the issues the original release had, it's still one of the most broken and ineptly designed games I have ever played. The writing is decent I guess(The Witcher book series is highly overrated IMO, and the author is a really arrogant jerk and something of a hack), but the gameplay is horrendous. Combat uses a stance and sort of rhythm system with counters and timed attacks which sounds like it should be fun, but it's so unintuitive and poorly implemented that you'd swear it was never playtested....and knowing what we know now about CDPR, it probably wasn't. Visually it was barely passable even at release, and has so many unintuitive and overly complicated systems like crafting and potion-making that supposedly are really important to the game, but you'll likely get way too frustrated trying to decipher the nonsense to really get into it. The absolute worst part of the game, however, is the community. The fans are insane. Much like diehards of any community, The Witcher fanboys are some of the most toxic people out there. Just go through this review section. Notice all the glowing 5-star reviews and how they all have dozens of people upvoting them, while all the negative or just middling reviews have like 1 or 2 people even engaging with them. Odds are it'll happen here too. The community really doesn't like admitting that this game sucks really bad. The Witcher 2 is okay and 3 is allegedly really good(I didn't like the first two games enough to try the third one), but they will crucify anyone that talks negatively about any of these games or the franchise in general.
Is this helpful to you?