Silent Hill 4: The Room

First half's mediocre, second half is atrocious. Do yourself a favor and play Silent Hill 1, 2, and 3, and don't bother with this one. Puzzles and map design are far, far weaker than the prior three games to the point where most worlds are just set dressing, and the second half of the game has your backtracking through the first half with even less to interact with, but with significantly more irritating enemy encounters, and an annoying, mandatory escort quest that determines your ending. Inventory management starts off interesting enough, but quickly becomes tedious, making you either skip over items because you can't hold onto them, or make time-consuming trips back to your apartment to sort items out (and there's no way of dropping items on the spot either, so no way to, say, consolidate ammo if you find a pickup).

The voice acting is weak, the combat is awkward and uncomfortable. Henry is cute but lacks a personality. However the atmosphere and story are intense and harrowing, a flawed but worthy send off to the Team Silent era.

besides the clunky mechanics signature for that era of gaming, it just keeps crashing :/

You just wander around aimlessly hitting dogs with a pipe, there's some creepy cutscenes and some good scary ambiance and then... I mean it's just such a mess overall, I really think that the game hasn't aged well at all. Silent Hill 2 is older and I thought it had aged much better than this.

Silent Hill 4 gets a lot of points for trying an original approach. You start in a "hub world" of your apartment, where some sinister lock keeps you inside and you cannot contact the outside world. Enter a portal to different levels. The apartment portion is a neat 1st person adventure approach. Some interesting and creepy stuff can happen there. The levels are ok, nothing great. Making healing items rare, but heal for free if you can make it back to the apartment is a more tense approach. Unfortunately, it all goes to crap halfway through. You're stuck with a permanent escort quest, you reuse all the same levels, it turns into annoying attrition as you cannot heal at the apartment anymore, and you're attacked by new annoying enemies. What really kills the 2nd half, is that it becomes an attrition slog where you desperately need certain limited items that you've been finding all game, but you're never told their value and aren't expecting the sudden halfway point shift in gameplay. It's very easy to waste all the items early on when you don't need them and don't know you'll need them later. Important effects of certain items are never explained. A seemingly harmless item will screw you over in the long term if you pick it up. Burping nurses are dumb. There's enough good here for a mild recommendation to series fans, but do yourself a big favor and set the difficulty to easy to avoid the immense frustration of the 2nd half.