Posted on: March 1, 2010

antihippie

Games: 195 Reviews: 52

Great Adventure Title

GK:2 stands out as probably the best of a brief spate of games that came out in the 90s featuring live actors in streaming video. The game uses excellent actors, a simplified and intuitive method of interaction and a compelling story-line to perfect what was always a flawed gaming system and deliver a fantastic, deep adventure game. The Beast Within is, obviously a sequel. It rejoins Gabriel Knight, now as a struggling Shattenjaeger in Germany trying to solve a string of murders involving a suspected werewolf. Unlike most sequels, which just provide more of the same, GK:2 reinvents itself. Due to the method of using live actors the interface has been completely retooled. No more do you have to choose between take, move, operate and speak commands. If you can use it, the cursor will change to a dagger and allow you to do so. There is a great deal to operate, which gives you a much greater feeling of being involved in the action than most games of this type. Unlike other live action games, which often leave you feeling like you're just passively watching a bad movie, GK:2 keeps you involved, making you feel like a detective in a dime store murder mystery. GK:2 stands out, for me, as the best of the series. The quality of the series fell off sharply in the third installment as it attempted to make a transition to full 3-d. Here however, the game designers manage to transition beautifully into a new style, taking the best and discarding the worst.

Is this helpful to you?

Posted on: August 15, 2018

jakub.959

Games: 512 Reviews: 32

Do not be blinded by nostalgia

I played it on release and...oh my god... Okay, deep breaths. In Gabriel Knight Sins of fathers our hero is a sly, charismatic, somewhat... pervy yet very charming guy. In Gabriel Knight 2 our hero is a guy who was rejected from some B romance movie for being too bland and boring. Grace is... I am trying not to swear here, Grace is irritating woman who has a character of wet dirty rag. Entire game consists mostly of loading screens and watching the same animations over and over and over again because you are trying to trigger a new event by walking around...a lot. Puzzles? What puzzles! Monkey could solve this and I am not even kidding right now, I am 100% sure that a trained chimp could solve all the games puzzles. In fact chimp may even be better at it than a human considering that I often missed the puzzle since I ALREADY FIGURED OUT THE CLUE AND FORGOT THAT GABRIEL MUST FIGURE IT OUT TOO. Yes, this is one of the few adventure games in which your character feels dumber than the player...by a lot. FMV games are usually very bad, interface feels unresponsive (and no, I am not talking from today's point of view, I mean from that time, remember, played it on launch day!) and you do not even feel like you are progressing in game, you just walk around and click on things praying to all the gods that suffering will finally end. So is this the worst game ever? Sadly no. Because there are flashes of brilliance, entire game is like a monument to a wasted potential and you can see small glimpses of what this game could have been if they only sticked to traditional format. Jane Jensen writing is stellar as always and you will learn quite a lot about history from this game. In fact it is so interesting that you should buy it just for this. But this must be the only adventure game which is much more interesting to watch than to play.

Is this helpful to you?

Posted on: January 24, 2023

streetyson

Games: 51 Reviews: 32

FMV is the future - or should've been

The heyday of 1990s FMV (full motion video) games. No finer example, imho. I wish more had been done with FMV, but thereafter games went to naff early 3D (which took another decade to be as nice to look at as FMV) or went down the interactive-movie route (which frankly bore me). Sure, today's 3D AAA games make FMV redundant/dated, but I feel what could've been another decade of FMV gaming was abandoned before it's time. Compare these previews to the 3D ones in Gabriel Knight 3 - 3D would be trash for at least another decade. Story-wise you get a nice sense of the mystery. I'm only knocking a star off for some typically clunky 1990s gameplay sequencing - eg a neat little location I found and searched thoroughly for evidence, but presumably earlier than the expected sequence because nothing was there - but when later stuck I eventually went back there and the evidence was now magically in place, presumably having been triggered by a certain conversation/sequence. Why not have the have it there but alternatively later enable a conversation about it? Painful - but thankfully there isn't much of that.

Is this helpful to you?

Posted on: March 10, 2012

Attikusx

Verified owner

Games: 21 Reviews: 2

My Favorite FMV game

I gotta be honest, and maybe it's strictly 'nostalgia' speaking, but this is my favorite FMV type game. I first played this on Win95 when I was about 12 years old or so. The plot is fantastic, the controls are pretty easy to get used to(much improved from the 1st game with the cursor changing mechanics). While the acting isn't exactly 'top notch'(notice Gabe's head tilt EVERYTIME he says something), it's still very entertaining for a game that came out at that time. If you can somehow get your hands on the book based on this game, do so(it isn't cheap anymore >.< ). My ONLY complaint is that Mosely isn't in this game, unlike the 1st and 3rd installments.

Is this helpful to you?

Posted on: July 3, 2022

neumi5694

Verified owner

Games: 3339 Reviews: 138

Fun localization

Gabriel tries to get into his role as Schattenjäger, even if he still really understands, what it means. He is called to Munich to look for what appears to be a Werewolf. At that time the game came out FMVs were the next big thing, so of course they tried to follow the trend. I never really liked the actor, even if he did a good job, I was just too used to Tim Curry's voice. But he would not have suited the role. Ths story is nice, brings you to some iconic in and around Munich, with references (and dreams/visions) of long dead kings and composers. Gabriel doesn't know German, sometimes he does not understand what people say, so for the German localization they had to think of something. While most of the time people speak plain German for everything Gabriel understands, those who say something that he doesn't understand, speak in a bavarian dialect which is used in the region.

Is this helpful to you?

Discover CD PROJEKT RED games

Highlights

Featured

Close, but not an exact hit

Gabriel Knight 2: The Beast Within

Other ratings

Add a review

Edit a review

Delete this review?

Report this review

Additional Details (required):

Report this review