Posted on: August 21, 2025

Lime_Juice4
Bestätigter BesitzerSpiele: 145 Rezensionen: 26
Great foundation for a successful series
CD Projekt Red took a bold leap by adapting Andrzej Sapkowski's novels. The Witcher is far from perfect, but it's an ambitious debut notable for atmosphere, choices, and worldbuilding. The start is rough: clumsy introductions, stiff cutscenes, awkwardly written characters. Combat is rhythm-based with timed clicks and multiple styles, but quickly becomes repetitive. The introduction of characters like Alvin in Chapter 1 is so bizarre and poorly integrated that it likely turned many players off. I often wonder that this series got the oppurtunity to grow and it is a harsh failing in more ways than one. Yet, if you look past the flaws, the game lays the foundation for one of the most acclaimed RPG franchises. A clever choice is Geralt returning with amnesia, letting players explore the world without prior lore knowledge. Decisions matter: choices in early chapters echo later, often forcing morally grey decisions where truth is elusive. One early choice support a witch or a suspicious mob perfectly illustrates the game's approach to moral ambiguity. What the game does best is atmosphere. The world doesn't revolve around Geralt and townsfolk have their own worries. Locations like Vizima feel detailed and lived in, with NPCs performing routines that make the world feel real. Visually, the game is ambitious: character models show their age, but environments are crafted with care. The story improves over time, though Chapters 4 and 5 feel rushed and some plot points are confusing. Major book characters like Yennefer or Ciri are largely unmentioned, a noticeable omission. Despite its flaws, The Witcher is a passionate, impressive debut. CD Projekt Red stretched their limited resources to create a world with scope, soul, and ambition. It laid the shaky foundation for later masterpieces, and its story and writing already hint at the talent that would define the series. Playing it isn't essential before The Witcher III, but it's still worth it.
Hilft dir das weiter?