fistynuts: From an old and long-lapsed pilot, the go-to stick for me and my friends used to be to the Saitek Cyborg 3D or 3D Gold. Amazingly enough it still fully works under Win 7 64-bit and is very adjustable.
I've never been able to master my Saitek Cyborg Evo; it's spent most of its lifetime in the cupboard. I never became an ace at IL2 :'(
The older 3D gold does look better!
I find it to be very sensitive to the lightest of touches; making it hard to aim accurately. I'll have to try it with the palm rest off.
I think I'd prefer something which pushed back/offered more resistance.
The throttle is in a bad place. I also find that it's too easy to twist the stick (z-axis) in normal movement.
Of course I may just be a rubbish pilot and should stick to using the mouse; there's lots of keyboard commands after all ;)