It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
tburger: this
avatar
Wealin: I know is off topic but what the hell happened to those guys? I know there was a time when you had to have an account to download, which for me was a little shifty for that sort of thing.
Um, I was on that site just yesterday. They're still very much around.
avatar
StingingVelvet: What's the point of buying any media? It's ALL free on the internet.

Your concern is valid but way behind the curve. The reason people buy games on PC is because they want to purchase them, simple as that. No one is buying games on the PC because they can't get them for free.
avatar
lukaszthegreat: you are right but people are not aware that abandonia is hosting pirated games. they believe its alright while pirating is not. just look at this thread.
"its grey area"
"its not a crime"

and abandonia does not do anything to change that viewpoint therefore they are to blame for the abuse which happens.
There are a great many of us out there who simply don't care that it's a crime because we realize that being a crime doesn't necessarily make something wrong. That being said, if I can buy it on GOG, I do. In several cases, I've bought the GOG version with no intention of playing it, just so I can have a definitive, legal copy.

You are not incorrect in your assesment. You are just taking a very black/white, right/wrong stance, as you are certainly free to do. But be aware that your argument will have little effect on most of us.
avatar
StingingVelvet: Well I don't know what the official definition of internet piracy is, if there even is one, but to me when there is no option to buy a game anywhere you're not stealing, harming or even disrespecting anyone by downloading it from an abandonware site. There is no one hurt by the action, no one who should be getting money that isn't.
avatar
keeveek: So fucking not true.
Think about this. I have a book that I wrote. It's mine. I DON'T WANT TO SELL IT TO ANYBODY.
And you, or guys like you would say "hey! it's abandonware! let's upload this on rapidshare!"
Which is totally bullshit.

The owner is the only person in the world, who decides to sell or not to sell. Even when you don't know who the owner is. If he doesn't want to sell and you download his program without permission - you are pirating this game. Period.
Who cares?
Post edited September 10, 2011 by Clocknova
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: The "ownership" that copyright provides only has meaning because it is granted by the law, and more generally by society itself. When much of society no longer sees any reason to buy into the idea of copyright in certain situations (such as abandonware) then the "ownership" that was granted by society to begin with quickly starts to lose any kind of meaning. If you want people to start buying back into the idea of "ownership" that copyright confers then you need to start giving them a reason to do so. Otherwise you can just continue to rage impotently while the rest of society simply does as they please.
avatar
keeveek: So you would feel ok If I copied tour vaccine and get all the profit? ( I remember you work for pharma companies)

PS. In Poland much over 60% people are pirating software. By your means it mean piracy should be legal here. Because society thinks it's ok. Billions of flies can't be wrong.
You really need to chill out, man. Find a better cause to channel your passion into. The ethics of software distribution is just sooooo unimportant in the grand scheme of things.
avatar
tfishell: Seems like I've opened a can of worms. Shit.

Anyways, personally I think the site /should/ host games that are extremely hard to find or expensive. Ones that can be purchased should be taken down, though.


isn't that a conflict?

and what is expensive?

people said that ultima 1-3 being sold here for six bucks is too expensive. can i now pirate it?
I don't really want to argue about it. :P This seems like a really strong issue to you, and nothing I doubt anything I say will change your mind. (However, when I wrote that I specifically had in mind how a new copy of System Shock 2 is about $400 on Amazon; I suppose one could purchase used copies there, too, however.)
avatar
tfishell: Seems like I've opened a can of worms. Shit.

Anyways, personally I think the site /should/ host games that are extremely hard to find or expensive. Ones that can be purchased should be taken down, though.
avatar
tfishell:


isn't that a conflict?

and what is expensive?

people said that ultima 1-3 being sold here for six bucks is too expensive. can i now pirate it?
avatar
tfishell: I don't really want to argue about it. :P This seems like a really strong issue to you, and nothing I doubt anything I say will change your mind. (However, when I wrote that I specifically had in mind how a new copy of System Shock 2 is about $400 on Amazon; I suppose one could purchase used copies there, too, however.)
I would never pay that kind of money for an old game. Lets say if GOG sold their old games for say 19.99 and 29.99 instead of 5.99 and 9.99, I would not buy any of the games because thats above what I think is a fair price for an old game, so I will look elsewhere. But in GOGs case, they were not greedy and priced their games reasonably so they have my business.

avatar
DarrkPhoenix: snip
avatar
keeveek: 9 out of 10 mp3 on Polish hard drive's / ipods are illegal. It means that pirating music in Poland should be legal, by your means. Because society thinks music copyrights are bullshit.

I can't accept how Polish folks think about copyright just because they are in majority.

What you say, is "crowd was right to kill Socrates, because he was overvoted."
I was talking to a gamer from Poland and he told me that he could get any game for free on the internet and that most Polish gamers he knew never buy games at retail and pirate almost all their games.
Post edited September 11, 2011 by Heretic777
avatar
Heretic777: I was talking to a gamer from Poland and he told me that he could get any game for free on the internet and that most Polish gamers he knew never buy games at retail and pirate almost all their games.
This is true. But it's changing. We've got copyright law since 1994 and before that date it was legal in Poland to pirate everything, even software for companies.

Also, comparing to salaries, music/videos are much more expensive than in other countries. For example, as a cashier in Tesco you will work 1 to 2 hours to earn money for new album. In Poland the same person would have to work for 5 to 6 hours, sometimes even more.

But I have many friends who buy games, and that number is growing. It's not so bright when it comes to music though. I personally don't know anybody, who doesn't have pirated music.
avatar
hedwards: That argument is frequently used in the US to justify legalizing marijuana. It's a bullshit argument and legalizing something because a sizable minority refuses to recognize the rule of law is a significant step towards anarchy.
I was thinking. And then I was thinking more. And I still don't find any link between marijuana and anarchy.
I can find a link between forbidding people to smoke whatever the hell they want and totalitarism, though.

In fact, in Czech Repubilc all kinds of drugs are legal (even heroin) in certain amounts. And CzR is doing fine. On the other hand, U.S. govt is wasting money on "war on drugs" and U.S. every year is one step closer to anarchy because of national debt. When your govt. won't be able to pay for Obama's social welfare, THEN you will see anarchy.

And CzR will be still fine, with all drugs legal.
Post edited September 11, 2011 by keeveek
avatar
Clocknova: You are not incorrect in your assesment. You are just taking a very black/white, right/wrong stance, as you are certainly free to do. But be aware that your argument will have little effect on most of us.
i had been speaking only about legality not morality. that's why its black and white.


avatar
tfishell: I don't really want to argue about it. :P This seems like a really strong issue to you, and nothing I doubt anything I say will change your mind. (However, when I wrote that I specifically had in mind how a new copy of System Shock 2 is about $400 on Amazon; I suppose one could purchase used copies there, too, however.)
im just posting a flaw in your argument.

everyone has different attitude to what is expensive. for some 100 dollars might not be expensive and for others paying 2 dollars is expensive.
avatar
orcishgamer: Please read some Lawrence Lessig, and actual attorney who's argued copyright before the USSC. His material is valuable even to non-US citizens.
i will try to do that. thx

Copyright isn't what you think it is, it's merely an exclusive monopoly on distribution. If may be "you're song" but once you sing it you can't really stop someone else from singing it. Once you tell your story it'll be retold, maybe modified first maybe not.

That exclusive monopoly ends, it's not a natural right in the US at least, it's granted and only insomuch as the public domain benefits from it.

The bullshit that has ensued over copyright is epic and really I don't give a fuck about the batshit insane creators that want to profit off their work for perpetuity. Frankly I can't think of very many fantasy games or books, for example, that don't rip off a good portion of Tolkien's ideas, that is how culture is supposed to work.

Culture is more important than that and we're hastily burying it. If it weren't for abandonware sites some of these games would have been lost forever. The fucking sourcecode to Adventure was almost lost forever. That would have been tragic. Some dude had a backup on an ancient type of storage device, on a whim he jury rigged some wiring to see what was on there and found it.

The way people push copyright these days is immoral and selfish.
you are talking about public benefits. Why should I care about public? its my life, my work. because it can be copied more easily than a house i build why anyone supposed to benefit from it without my consent?
Culture? yes. we supposed to preserve culture, encourage it. Yet if author wants to his work to be gone its his/her right to do so. Its their property to which you should have no right the same way you have no right to their cars, land etc.
Because it can be copied much easier is completely irrelevant.
You say you don't care about batshit insane creators. They worked to create something and you believe that you can take it. fuck that.

that being said there is a problem with copyright laws. They are far from perfect.
Post edited September 11, 2011 by lukaszthegreat
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: Funny, there's quite a few members of the public who would throw those sentiments right back at content creators. And at the end of the day the public holds just about all the cards on this matter. So you might want to try to play nice, otherwise you'll just get a big "Fuck you!" from a large portion of the public as they happily download whatever they please. And there won't be anything meaningful you can do about it.
of course they would. they want free stuff without putting any work. that's not honest and fair tough.

edit: sorry. hoped the post will be merged :(
Post edited September 11, 2011 by lukaszthegreat
avatar
lukaszthegreat: Culture? yes. we supposed to preserve culture, encourage it. Yet if author wants to his work to be gone its his/her right to do so. Its their property to which you should have no right the same way you have no right to their cars, land etc.
Amen to that. This topic should end after that sentence. Thank you, sir!
Well, doesn't look like this discussion is going to go any further. Feel free to carry on with your pointless rage and frustration.
avatar
lukaszthegreat: Yet if author wants to his work to be gone its his/her right to do so. Its their property to which you should have no right the same way you have no right to their cars, land etc.
He made an effort once to sell it to me. He made it go into the wild blue consumerism and demanded his share. He polluted my visual and memory sections of the brain with his awesome ideas, and now he wants them to disappear. I take special offense with that, so I take special steps to fight it.
avatar
keeveek: In fact, in Czech Repubilc all kinds of drugs are legal (even heroin) in certain amounts. And CzR is doing fine.
This is not exactly true. They are not legal, the law only says (quite famously) that unless you are in possession of "a greater than small amount" of drugs, you will not be persecuted. The definition of this amount is intentionally left vague, though the police apparently has some internal guideline tables. It's a legal backdoor of sorts, nothing else. Drugs are still illegal, though the society here is quite tolerant when it comes to the light stuff.

Sorry for the off-topic, everyone keep arguing, please. For me, I don't see anything morally wrong with true abandonware, and don't care about the legality of it one bit.
avatar
bazilisek: snip
thanks for claryfication. I saw once somewhere a table with drug amount that won't be prosecuted in CzR.

And I think it's fine. Prosecuting drug USERS is a bad method of fighting it, and your govt. seems to understand that.
i think no civilized country at the moment can make drugs legal. even dutchland has laws written in a way which theoretically makes drugs illegal.

Read about some international laws prohibiting legality of drugs so countries have to create weird laws to allow people to smoke MJ. Holland does that and apparently Czech too :) never knew that.
So this place has turned from an opinion thread to an argument thread.

One of you just please tell me how to actually play the games from Abandonia?
avatar
Landeril: So this place has turned from an opinion thread to an argument thread.

One of you just please tell me how to actually play the games from Abandonia?
Uh, DOSBox bro. Or whatever other tweaking they may need.