Clocknova: You are not incorrect in your assesment. You are just taking a very black/white, right/wrong stance, as you are certainly free to do. But be aware that your argument will have little effect on most of us.
i had been speaking only about legality not morality. that's why its black and white.
tfishell: I don't really want to argue about it. :P This seems like a really strong issue to you, and nothing I doubt anything I say will change your mind. (However, when I wrote that I specifically had in mind how a new copy of System Shock 2 is about $400 on Amazon; I suppose one could purchase used copies there, too, however.)
im just posting a flaw in your argument.
everyone has different attitude to what is expensive. for some 100 dollars might not be expensive and for others paying 2 dollars is expensive.
orcishgamer: Please read some Lawrence Lessig, and actual attorney who's argued copyright before the USSC. His material is valuable even to non-US citizens.
i will try to do that. thx
Copyright isn't what you think it is, it's merely an exclusive monopoly on distribution. If may be "you're song" but once you sing it you can't really stop someone else from singing it. Once you tell your story it'll be retold, maybe modified first maybe not.
That exclusive monopoly ends, it's not a natural right in the US at least, it's granted and only insomuch as the public domain benefits from it.
The bullshit that has ensued over copyright is epic and really I don't give a fuck about the batshit insane creators that want to profit off their work for perpetuity. Frankly I can't think of very many fantasy games or books, for example, that don't rip off a good portion of Tolkien's ideas, that is how culture is supposed to work.
Culture is more important than that and we're hastily burying it. If it weren't for abandonware sites some of these games would have been lost forever. The fucking sourcecode to Adventure was almost lost forever. That would have been tragic. Some dude had a backup on an ancient type of storage device, on a whim he jury rigged some wiring to see what was on there and found it.
The way people push copyright these days is immoral and selfish.
you are talking about public benefits. Why should I care about public? its my life, my work. because it can be copied more easily than a house i build why anyone supposed to benefit from it without my consent?
Culture? yes. we supposed to preserve culture, encourage it. Yet if author wants to his work to be gone its his/her right to do so. Its their property to which you should have no right the same way you have no right to their cars, land etc.
Because it can be copied much easier is completely irrelevant.
You say you don't care about batshit insane creators. They worked to create something and you believe that you can take it. fuck that.
that being said there is a problem with copyright laws. They are far from perfect.