Posted June 03, 2016
I just came home from the movie and was surprised no one's talking about it here. I guess it has such a staggered release around the world, who knows where it's out right now.
Well, speaking as someone whose only experience with the world of Azeroth is a brief time playing Hearthstone last year, and reading some of the games' synopses a long time ago, I quite enjoyed it. What I recognized mostly was some of the names, and a "for the horde!" sound bite I'm fairly certain was lifted directly from the games. And the Wilhelm scream. That got a chuckle from the audience, which I think was the intended reaction. I've heard said the movie was impenetrable to general moviegoing audiences, but apart from a single major instance, there wasn't anything you couldn't just infer or just roll with it.
The one thing I didn't get is related to one of the villains motivations. He was clearly corrupted in some way, but it wasn't explained how that came to pass. Maybe a proper Warcraft fan can explain that one. Despite writing "spoilers" in the title, I might refrain from going into it for at least a couple of pages, or until someone else who's seen it shows up to discuss it.
-
On the quality of the movie itself:
It has some clunky writing. Some of the scenes end quite abruptly, giving the feel there was a lot more left on the cutting room floor. Overall you can clearly see it's an adaptation, by that I mean it feels like a condensed version of something else. A lot of the human characters are very archetypical, the noble king, the wise mage, the brave hero, but they work as they're supposed to in the story.
The orcs came off as some of the most sympathetic characters. There was a lot of internal conflict in a lot of them and, aside from the big bad Gul'dan, none of them seemed evil. The action was great. Very over the top, like orcs picking up and throwing a horse. Magic seemed appropriately impressive, which is a rare thing in movies. LotR had very little of it, and Harry Potter is just pewpewpew lasers back and forth for the most part. The CGI didn't look out of place. It looks quite cartoony, which I think is much easier to do than trying to emulate something real. The humans were able to fit alongside the CGI characters, which was a concern of mine, no doubt aided by the brightly colored armor.
-
In the end, it's a fun pulp high fantasy movie, that's all. It's no masterpiece, it's not brilliantly written or a deep look into the human soul, and that's fine. People sometimes seem stuck in a "best movie ever/worst movie ever" mentality, but there's a place for nuance in between. Once you realize this is a cheesy pulp fantasy story, you adjust your expectations and enjoy it for what it is, and that's what this was, a chessy pulp high fantasy story and a fun time at the movies.
Then again, a lot of people hate John Carter (most without having watched it, I suspect), and I thought that was just a fun pulp science fantasy story, so keep that in mind when I rate this similarly.
P.S.: Sorry for the wall of text. I always try to contain myself and it never works.
Well, speaking as someone whose only experience with the world of Azeroth is a brief time playing Hearthstone last year, and reading some of the games' synopses a long time ago, I quite enjoyed it. What I recognized mostly was some of the names, and a "for the horde!" sound bite I'm fairly certain was lifted directly from the games. And the Wilhelm scream. That got a chuckle from the audience, which I think was the intended reaction. I've heard said the movie was impenetrable to general moviegoing audiences, but apart from a single major instance, there wasn't anything you couldn't just infer or just roll with it.
The one thing I didn't get is related to one of the villains motivations. He was clearly corrupted in some way, but it wasn't explained how that came to pass. Maybe a proper Warcraft fan can explain that one. Despite writing "spoilers" in the title, I might refrain from going into it for at least a couple of pages, or until someone else who's seen it shows up to discuss it.
-
On the quality of the movie itself:
It has some clunky writing. Some of the scenes end quite abruptly, giving the feel there was a lot more left on the cutting room floor. Overall you can clearly see it's an adaptation, by that I mean it feels like a condensed version of something else. A lot of the human characters are very archetypical, the noble king, the wise mage, the brave hero, but they work as they're supposed to in the story.
The orcs came off as some of the most sympathetic characters. There was a lot of internal conflict in a lot of them and, aside from the big bad Gul'dan, none of them seemed evil. The action was great. Very over the top, like orcs picking up and throwing a horse. Magic seemed appropriately impressive, which is a rare thing in movies. LotR had very little of it, and Harry Potter is just pewpewpew lasers back and forth for the most part. The CGI didn't look out of place. It looks quite cartoony, which I think is much easier to do than trying to emulate something real. The humans were able to fit alongside the CGI characters, which was a concern of mine, no doubt aided by the brightly colored armor.
-
In the end, it's a fun pulp high fantasy movie, that's all. It's no masterpiece, it's not brilliantly written or a deep look into the human soul, and that's fine. People sometimes seem stuck in a "best movie ever/worst movie ever" mentality, but there's a place for nuance in between. Once you realize this is a cheesy pulp fantasy story, you adjust your expectations and enjoy it for what it is, and that's what this was, a chessy pulp high fantasy story and a fun time at the movies.
Then again, a lot of people hate John Carter (most without having watched it, I suspect), and I thought that was just a fun pulp science fantasy story, so keep that in mind when I rate this similarly.
P.S.: Sorry for the wall of text. I always try to contain myself and it never works.
Post edited June 03, 2016 by DaCostaBR