I got:
Party Hard - $12.89
Battle Worlds: Kronos - $19.99

I'm very happy about Party Hard :)

The reason I'm not interested at all in Hybrid Wars is that I really dislike top-down shooters, twin-stick shooters and the likes.
I loved Hotline Miami, but that played more like a puzzle game, if anything. I don't like stuff like Alien Breed or Crusader.

BTW, I checked the list and decided I was unlucky, since most of the games I don't own already are decent and there are actually more titles I'm looking for than titles I don't like, therefore I decided to try my luck again.
I found:

Earthlock: Festival of Magic
Cities in Motion
Soldiers: Heroes of World War II
Antihero

The only one I don't particularly like here is Soldiers: HOWWII, just because I'm also not a fan of RTS games, but the other 3 look good and Antihero was even in my wishlist.

Well, more stars than I thought I'd buy....

>observer_
Beat Cop
Butcher
Crawl
Crime Cities
Delta Force: Black Hawk Down Platinum Pack
Furi
Game of Thrones: A Telltale Games Series
Hacknet
Homeworld: Deserts of Kharak
Homeworld: Emergence
Hybrid Wars
Kim
Kingdom: New Lands
Knights of the Pen and Paper +1 Deluxier Edition
LEGO Batman 2 DC Super Heroes
Mon O' War: Corsair - Warhammer Naval Battles
On Rust Trails
Phantom Trigger
Samorost 3
Scanner Sombre
Serpent in the Staglands
Sexy Brutale, The
Silence
Tahira: Echoes of the Astral Empire
Think of the Children
UnderRail
War for the Overworld
Wuppo

Well, i just bought one little star to test my luck. I was hoping for Corpse Party, since i never got to play it when it came out, but ended up getting Beat Drums...

Torchlight 2.

I'm not mad at all tbh, i love those types of games, so i know i'll be spending ALL of my holiday hours on it, it's just that i feel like playing some horror games as of right now and i was hoping Corpse Party would quench my thirst.

Just opened 3 stars and got:

Transistor
Sam and Max: The Devil's Playhouse
Timelapse

Bought one more, might buy some more before the weekend.

King's Bounty: Crossworlds GOTY

Actually looks like something I'd really enjoy, not that I've played it before. But happy enough with it.

So far I've got:

Dreamfall Chapters: The Final Cut
Little Big Adventure 2 (Twinsen's Odyssey)
Warrior Kings
Homeworld: Deserts of Kharak
Death to Spies: Moment of Truth
The Walking Dead: Season 2

Pretty good run if you ask me.

I got Astebreed: Definitive Edition

I've pushed my luck about as far as I'm willing to with 4 stars.

Jagged Alliance 2
Lego Batman
The Sexy Brutale
Homeworld: Deserts of Kharak

I think I've got a good haul.

Astonishigly good!

With Digerati games among the stars.... no way in Hell am I buying a star.

So far it's been

Skyshine's Bedlam Redux (Might be okay...? Not into turn-based, much)
Bit Trip Fate (Never played one)
Overclocked: A History of Violence (The mechanics sound really annoying)
Back to the Future (Telltale)
Homeworld Emergence (I've learned to like RTS games thanks to the last mystery game sale but I don't know if I'll like this one)
Solidiers: Heroes of WWII (The RTS I liked from the last one looked like this so, maybe)
Game of Thrones (Telltale...I seriously wish I'd stop getting those)
Dreamfall Chapters: Final Cut (Please stop giving me story games)
Prison Architect (This might be okay, I like managerial games sometimes)

I've been sticking too one a day but even that I can't really afford. I'm not crazy about my haul so far but a lot of the stuff I would have hoped to get I already purchased. Between this one and the last one I've never gotten a single wishlist item, either.

I shouldn't, having way too many games in my library,
but with one star a day, I got:

BIT.TRIP FLUX
Death to Spies: Moment of Truth
Furi
Perception
Quern - Undying Thoughts
Scanner Sombre
Skyshine's BEDLAM Redux!
* Torchlight II (not on the list)
Warrior Kings
Ys I & II Chronicles+

I opened 3 stars and got:

Battle Worlds: Kronos
Order of the Thorne: The King's Challenge
Darwinia

I don't see it on the list, but I got S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Call of Pripyat