Bookwyrm627: For all that seem to be missing gift codes, I just double checked the FAQ. Bolding is mine:
5) How, and when, will I receive my free game?Once you start unlocking games, you can find the redeemable game keys by clicking on the "Check Progress" button next to your counter. Soon after you unlock the reward, we'll email you with a gift code redeemable at gog.com/redeem. You can claim it for yourself or pass it on to a friend.
It might take a few hours for the message to be delivered, so please be patient.
Yes, I lost my last freebie too.
And yes, it says that the
message might take a few hours to be delivered. Mainly because it's not up to them how the email works, and if it works. But that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be in the "learn more" popup. And mine is not.
Basically, my hypothesis right now is 50%/50% between a bug with giving you the free game, or a bug with taking the counter down when they get out of freebies.