It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Crosmando: Why? So anyone can make Dune games which aren't loyal to the source material in any way, like what has happened to HP Lovecraft?
avatar
tinysalamander: Why not? There are many “aren't loyal to the source material” games which are loved by fans. You might get a bit of that, and a bit of that, or who knows what entirely, but there is opportunity.

With “eternal” copyright you get nothing other than what someone approved. And that someone can't even write a single good Dune book :/ The more works you get, the more chance you have to get at least something of substance.
How would YOU feel if you spent the better part of your whole life writing a novel series and then saw it abused to make crappy games which neither understood nor cared about the source material. Copyright exists for people to protect their intellectual property.
avatar
Crosmando: How would YOU feel if you spent the better part of your whole life writing a novel series and then saw it abused to make crappy games which neither understood nor cared about the source material. Copyright exists for people to protect their intellectual property.
I'd feel pretty fine, actually.

Copyright exists to give a limited time monopoly so an author might have some incentive to create more works and after that works goes to public domain to enrich humanity's culture. Copyright is not a tool get infinite money or “protection”, even if it used that way.

Everything you create in some way is derivative of something else created before you. Author doesn't exist in a vacuum. If you stop public domain from growing you only slow down humanity's culture.

And Frank Herbert is long dead. He won't write a single book anymore. Which makes granting a monopoly over his works useless.
Post edited March 01, 2019 by tinysalamander
Well the Westwood Dune games introduced me to the Dune universe so I can understand some part of Herbert's complaint since House Ordos do not exist in the books and I was a bit confused when I started reading the books as where they were (catching on that they must have been made for the game).

However the estate could appreciate that the games are doing a service of bringing in more readers and fans to the Dune universe as I never even heard of the franchise before playing the games.

My experience is probably very similar for many people who are fans of The Witcher series as well as It is probably safe to say many current fans started with the games then transitioned to the books.
avatar
Swedrami: From their 4th quarter of 2018 financial report:

"Exclusive gaming partnership established with Legendary Entertainment for the creation of a minimum of 3 games based on the DUNE Intellectual Property over the next six years, on PC and Console"

"Finally, we are very excited to announce an exclusive gaming partnership with Legendary Entertainment to develop a line of video games based on the works of Frank Herbert’s DUNE. DUNE is one of the world’s best-known science fiction universes and a personal favourite of mine. To work on DUNE games is a dream come true for many of us in Funcom. We will talk more about what we will do in this fantastic universe in the future."

It's not mentioned in the report as far as I can tell, but other sites are claiming the first project to be an open-world MMO similar to some of Funcom's other MMOs, for example based on the Conan franchise.

Ugh.
That report might not eventually reveal that one Ole Herbjornsen might be the assigned lead for that project?

Just curious ; no reason at all .
One trading card game, one battle royale and one mobile cookie clicker.