Huh, so you were giving us an actual Deadline back then (somewhere between Tuesday and Friday) :D Well Frigga won I guess, or maybe it goes on into lördag (bathday).

General uneasiness based on the low profile she seemed to keep and mostly because of the way she handled the pseudo roll call.

I forgot to ask about this. Knowing now that groups consists of myself, Hunter and HSL - what is making it that surprising?

1) Lift, HSL, and you

2) I sometimes copy the list of players from the OP into Notepad, delete names that are dead or that I think are town, and then see who is left; I found myself kind of surprised when your two names still happened to be on that list. Thus, the rereading I need to do to see whether the misgivings solidify or dissipate.

I should also reread Lift. Reviewing the posts from Trent and Hunter would also be a good idea.

(And while I'm at it, I may as well reread Mchack and Flub. Then me and Krypsyn, and if the Day hasn't ended, maybe even JMich.)

Sorry, I meant Lift. I confused your and HSL's lists a bit. I risk doing something I said I don't like personally, but I still don't understand what makes it surprising and I'm curious :)

The surprise is just a knee-jerk reaction, existing I think because I generally read the two of you as town. I'm afraid there isn't any more explanation to it.

Thank you.

Since I was asked and actually didn't comment on Hunter: I find him very hard to read. He seems to be keeping a low profile. He asks some questions and other than others he actually seems to want to understand the answers and motivations and is not only looking for weak spots to exploit. Fair play? Or lacking drive to hunt scum because he is CL himself? I don't know. I had him as leaning town so far, but I am worried that he is indeed trying to keep a low profile so that we lynch some active player (his suggestion is HSL). Everyone knows that this is a weakness of this entire community. We always go for the active players. So Hunter's keeping it low but participating enough that he can't be accused of lurking would be very good play as a CL.

About my vote on flubb: no, I'm not sure that he is CL. I find him impossible to read and not very helpful. So this vote is both a fall-back solution and, hopefully, an incentive to become more useful and contribute something.

Betcha dollar I'm a disappointment.

Hunter was keeping it low until HSL pointed towards him which triggered a vote. I'm still waiting for him to share some more details on that vote, but what's your take on it?

Or actually wait for Hunter to come back and let him provide his own answer first. Then I may re-ask this. Things are starting to get messy, though.

oh my I took quite a long time to scrape the thread, make a json out of the data, analyse it (well see who posted how many times) and render me a chart from that, to prove that hunter might be lurking a bit.
But turns out he posted more often than others (me included) O.o
oh well I might say it's about quality not quantity, but I don't think I'd be better off with that line of argumentation. oh no.
anyway. since I put the work in, I'll just add the chart but I do think it helps exactly about nothing :(


(OFF-TOPIC and I have to get up to work in 3 hours :( ah, the choices we make...
but if someone is interested in something like that for any other game, just pm me and I can send you a chart (the pie chart is nice, too) in no time, since the code's there and ready to go, just need to point it at any gog thread))

Mmm, pi.

@mods, did Hunter tell you something about being obstructed from playing in some way? His timestamp now says 2 days (even though it might be less than 48 hours).

I'm starting to have second thoughts...

Post 275 is from yesterday.

You are correct. I tried to ISO him with a silly one-line script, but I botched it and got a wrong post. Then he'll probably come back today.