crumb24: I really don't understand your hate for the Enhanced Editions, which you seem to need to post about in every thread anytime anyone brings them up., I agree that people trying the game out for the first time should try to play BG and BG2 without mods or Enhanced Editions. But if you want to try things a little differently on subsequent playthroughs, I see nothing wrong with using mods or in playing the Enhanced Editions. Are the Enhanced Editions for everyone? Obviously not. But if someone likes them, I don't see why you see the need to impose your opinion on everyone else. I haven't played all of the content in either BG:EE and BG2:EE, but what I've played so far I like. I don't get why its not okay for other people, including me, to like the Enhanced Editions. No one's opinions are facts. If you do not like the Enhanced Editions, that's fine. But my opinion is valid too. Its just a matter of personal preference and I don't get why you feel the need to scare off everyone from trying the Enhanced Editions.
Hickory: Don't assume you know me. I do not hate the Enhanced Editions. I have
two copies of each. I bought both from Beamdog, and both from GOG. I have played both. This is a forum. Forums are places for discussion. If you have a valid opinion you should state it. In the same vein, I do the same. I have never said, nor intimated, that my opinion is above anybody else's, nor that it's "not ok" to like the Enhanced Editions. My opinions count; your opinions count. Don't lose sight of that, and don't whine just because somebody's opinion is different from your own.
The issue is that you still haven't really elaborated on why you have a dislike for the Enhanced Editions or why it is you don't think people should play them. There are numerous little additions or enhancements present in the BG1:EE that are really nice to have, and issues/features that are fixed from vanilla Baldur's Gate. Not to mention playing an evil party is that much more fun now, there are some nice pieces of updated artwork for various things, some nice equipment updates/requirements are made, some nice different spell & effect animations, additional content makes bastard swords more viable which was heavily needed with how weapon proficiencies are more specific from the original BG, scimitars on a notable NPC are no longer pickpocketable, the new NPCs have some unique interactions and voice acting with original game NPCs, etc. etc. etc. I could go on, but I'll just end with saying character creation is much improved as well, with some additional portraits for you to choose from (the original Baldur's Gate only had 2 non-NPC female portraits to choose and 4 non-NPC male portraits to choose), as well as doubling the amount of voice sets you can pick from giving you more variety with the character you roll with (5 of the 6 new voice sets are nicely done IMO).
The one notable thing I didn't see them address would be giving you a more appropriate character portrait for a female dwarf, so you basically have to pick something like a halfling portrait unless you use mods for a portrait closer to a dwarf. Another criticism is that the original opening cutscene looks much more in style with what I think of Baldur's Gate than the motion comic version in the Enhanced Edition. Most the other cutscenes or updates in terms of art I've encountered have looked fine and I'm definitely okay with those, but the redone motion comic style doesn't really work for that opening cinematic compared to the original. I don't think it would have been too much work to redo it with hand drawn animation that didn't seem like corners were cut doing it motion comic style, but if they couldn't do redone animation right then they should have found a way to update the original cutscenes in higher resolution or some 3D workaround that didn't break the bank.
Now as I already talked about, it would have been one thing to have been saying things to the effect that the Enhanced Edition wasn't worth the money when you could just use mods for the original, that is when the Enhanced Edition first came out and didn't have as many fixes or present features as it does now. But now that the Enhanced Edition is in a very playable state with most in-game issues dealt with and additional features taken care of (like adding the Dwarven Defender fighter kit in a patch) I don't get what the issue is with playing the Enhanced Edition, especially if someone doesn't want to spend a bunch of time with mods or trying to figure out which mods to use and stuff. Some people just like to install a game and play, or plug and play. No content of the original game was removed, barring balancing out some starting equipment of an NPC to match updated proficiencies of characters. It's like if you go to a chinese restaurant and your preference is to always use chopsticks to eat your food because you enjoy it more then that's fine. But that doesn't mean that your friends eating with you also have to use chopsticks because you feel it's the better way to eat chinese.
If you would just explain and give us some reasons as to what's so wrong with the Enhanced Edition, we wouldn't have a problem with your opinions in the thread. But so far you haven't really posted anything to support your opinion that concerns something in the game itself, except for maybe the contention that buying the original and playing with mods instead is better and less expensive. And for the sake of argument, technically someone with access (like through a friend maybe) to the Enhanced Edition's additional portraits and voice sets could try modding them into the original game instead of just buying the Enhanced Edition. However, that would be a very dishonest thing to do and would be disrespectful to the people who did work on the Enhanced Edition.
I can't really say anything yet about BG2:EE since I haven't played that or the original BG2, though I did see in the reviews that the initial release was plenty buggy and unstable like the initial release of the BG1:EE. I can understand being upset about this and thinking if it becomes a pattern with Beamdog that it would be problematic using players as glorified testers. But as to the state of BG1:EE as it is right now, I see no reason why someone shouldn't play it if they're new to Baldur's Gate. If their best interest is to play the original release first, with or without modding, I'm sure they'll come to their own decision and play the original regardless what I say or you say about the EE.