Those wishes are duplicates of this one:
Add another
Comments (optional)
Cancel
Send report
This wish is a spam. Comments... (optional)
Cancel
Send report

It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like:Chrome,Firefox,Internet Explorer orOpera

×
Back to wishlist
Options
Share on
Report asDuplicate  Spam

Keep it clean

If you believe that a wish duplicates another one or is not meant for the category, use Options button above to report a duplicate or spam.

Add your wish

If there is an item you wish to have on GOG.com and it’s not yet on the wishlist, please add your wish

+7478
vote
voted

Quake

Added by besse's avatar besse besse's avatar besse Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}

51 comments about this wish

Add comment
My comment
Cancel
Post it
Jakub1975 Jakub1975 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

quake of course

Jun. 25, 2015
report
hide
Jakub1975 Jakub1975 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I am afraid qukae will never be on GOG... :-(

Jun. 25, 2015
report
hide
Hikage1983 Hikage1983 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I would love this since i lost my original CD when i moved.Voted!

Jun. 15, 2015
report
hide
iDoom iDoom Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Сюда бы оригинальную дос-версию, с саундтреком

Apr. 6, 2015
report
hide
danq84 danq84 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

And WITH the NIN music/boxes left intact!

Dec. 22, 2014
report
hide
RaggyRock RaggyRock Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake, with its mission packs, would be a welcome addition on GOG.com. Especially if it supported MacOS :)

Nov. 23, 2014
report
hide
Matruchus Matruchus Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

A must buy for sure. Arguably one of the best shooters of all time.

Oct. 25, 2014
report
hide
motionblur motionblur Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

first and foremost Quake isn't available on the german steam store.

Oct. 2, 2014
report
hide
anewsites anewsites Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

<a href="http://www.mjbulk.org" class="light_un" target="_blank">www.mjbulk.org</a> and www.lotnike.com

Sep. 26, 2014
report
hide
##@@##@@ ##@@##@@ Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

al por mayor <a href="http://www.eeuues.com/al-por-mayor/nike-air-max-exporter/" class="light_un" target="_blank">http://www.eeuues.com/al-por-mayor/nike-air-max-exporter/</a> zapatos nike max

Mar. 3, 2014
report
hide
GHofm GHofm Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake + MIssion Packs would be cool.

Feb. 21, 2014
report
hide
bluecorer bluecorer Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quys, this should be the query first qame qeleased in qere. Quake!

Feb. 21, 2014
report
hide
SenileAnimal SenileAnimal Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

The steam release is without music and is $$$, that alone should make a GOG version sell well. Plus many would much rather buy it here.

Feb. 19, 2014
report
hide
mkell_226 mkell_226 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Seriously, why are we even discussing this? It should've been released the moment Activision started releasing titles here!!

Feb. 12, 2014
report
hide
retrogamingdude3 retrogamingdude3 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

This is definitely a must-have game. Hope you can get it GOG.

Dec. 9, 2013
report
hide
BinaerGecko BinaerGecko Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake is love, Quake is live.

Nov. 22, 2013
report
hide
aassiotis9 aassiotis9 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake. On GOG. ASAP. PLEASE

Nov. 9, 2013
report
hide
shrike1313 shrike1313 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake, nuff said.

Oct. 26, 2013
report
hide
Psychomorph Psychomorph Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

QUUAAAAKE! <br /> <br /> Voted, expecting results.

Aug. 27, 2013
report
hide
zU84ha76la zU84ha76la Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

But don't forget to INCLUDE THE SOUNDTRACK!

Aug. 14, 2013
report
hide
sharp299 sharp299 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Please, PLEASE!!! <a href="http://Gog.com" class="light_un" target="_blank">Gog.com</a> NEED QUAKE!!!!!

Jul. 15, 2013
report
hide
why420 why420 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Dear GOG Team ;) <br /> I would love to see Quake on GOG.com! I live in Germany and sadly Quake is (by the time I'm writing this) still unavailable here. Doom's ban was lifted in 2011 which is absurd when you think about it and we still have to wait if Quake's ban will lift or not. <br /> The sad part is that even through Doom is now "legally" acquirable there is no available digital copy for PC accept for the Doom 3 BFG Edition. <br /> I could post this under every requested id software title but I feel that Quake is the one I should have experienced as a gamer and I would most love to own. <br /> To show you desperation: Even the (apparently) shitty steam version would be fine for me - at least for now. <br /> It's not like there is no digital for German costumers copy of this game at all. The id store offers Quake but I don't know what I will get. Will I be able to redownload the game any time after my purchase and will it be restricted by DRM? DRM does not concern me all that much in game unless it's an old title where I'm pretty sure that I'll have to modify the game to run proper. <br /> In conclusion I don't have great past memories of this game or other id titles and I would love the change this. So please GOG get this or even more id titles in your store! Help me to experience this blank part of gaming history. <br /> <br /> With love and gratefulness for all the stuff you already provided my through your site <br /> why420

May. 28, 2013
report
hide
graspee graspee Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I don't know why everyone is having problems with the steam version. There's plenty of source ports you can use and no DRM. Yes, it lacks the music, which is bad, but gog has released at least one game in the past missing its cd soundtrack.

May. 4, 2013
report
hide
Egud Egud Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I think the rights belong to Bethesda and they are very greedy.

Mar. 30, 2013
report
hide
FragAguy FragAguy Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake on GOG would be awesome!

Jan. 17, 2013
report
hide
Egud Egud Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Please! Release this game on GOG!!

Jan. 6, 2013
report
hide
KingKannibal KingKannibal Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Why is this still on the requested games section? is Activision too greedy, GOG? I do NOT wish to purchase this game on another distribution service because then I won't be able to play it in my LAN like I can with the Unreal Engine games already on <a class="light_un" href="http://GOG.com" target="_blank">GOG.com</a>!

Dec. 27, 2012
report
hide
hudfreegamer hudfreegamer Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I have Quake on disc, but I'm still in favor of making it available on GOG.

Dec. 20, 2012
report
hide
Limb0 Limb0 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

This better make it into GoG, I would get it on steam, but I don't want to, Quake 2 and 1 on there lack the music, which is dumb really, if GoG's versions at least adds the soundtrack as an extra (considering the fact the original game had to be played with the CD), Im so buying it here.

Dec. 14, 2012
report
hide
retrofreak_1974 retrofreak_1974 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I agree, GOG versions of old ID games would be great. I would've like to buy Quake 2 + mission packs today. (No, I don't want the Steam versions.)

Dec. 11, 2012
report
hide
Aztec Aztec Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

ID please Quake,Doom and Hexen on GOG.

Dec. 9, 2012
report
hide
011284mm 011284mm Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

The game of our youth. GOG and Bethesda really need to work together. I love how the gaming industry is always saying that we are unwilling to legally support them when GOG is proving that we pay for games we feel we have the rights to play where and when we like. As for Quake, the sound track by NineInchNails was a feast for the ears and really must be included with the game for the full enjoyment.

Nov. 27, 2012
report
hide
DustFalcon1985 DustFalcon1985 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Damn! Bad link. Here's the correct one: <a class="light_un" href="http://www.gog.com/wishlist/site/strike_a_deal_w_zenimax_media_inc" target="_blank">http://www.gog.com/wishlist/site/strike_a_deal_w_zenimax_media_inc</a>

Nov. 15, 2012
report
hide
DustFalcon1985 DustFalcon1985 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Hey guys. I created a wish in the Requested Site Features so that GOG strikes a deal w/ ZeniMax Media Inc. (Parent of Bethesda Softworks) Link: <a class="light_un" href="http://www.gog.com/wishlist/site/strike_a_deal_w_zenimax_media_incI" target="_blank">http://www.gog.com/wishlist/site/strike_a_deal_w_zenimax_media_incI</a> need your votes!

Nov. 15, 2012
report
hide
tbirdo tbirdo Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

If Bethesda/id isn't going to release decent Steam ports., they should really license it to gog to give these old games a proper PC rerelease. Other users have pointed out the problems. I'm surprised this game doesn't have a higher vote count.

Nov. 13, 2012
report
hide
fclarkism fclarkism Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

why have id's games not ended up on GOG yet... Quake, Doom, and Heretic/HeXen. I support this 100%!

Oct. 2, 2012
report
hide
Gaerzi Gaerzi Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I have that one on Steam; but on GOG it'd be better since I'm pretty sure that, contrarily to Valve, they'd think about the soundtrack...

Sep. 25, 2012
report
hide
bre bre Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I never had much interest in quake or any of the other classic shooters, but after reading some of the ancient history about them i wanted to check out the revolutionary fluidity etc. I once bought an id software pack on steam, which included quake. anyway, after playing for some 15 min and seeing how good it plays, i wondered why it was so quiet. though enjoyable, it seems the steam version is another quick and easy dump, without the original music or any loving polish. I will definitely re-buy this game for 10$ if it would show up here. If i had a twitter i would ask john carmack himself about the sub-par steam version, or even better, about a GOG version.

Sep. 2, 2012
report
hide
czwarty czwarty Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I would love this! Just make sure it includes the entire sountrack IN-GAME, as the Steam version is seriously lacking in that regard.

Aug. 31, 2012
report
hide
cynicalmatt cynicalmatt Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I reinstalled and started playing this only two days ago, but this time with Quake Epsilon. Completely forgot how much fun this game was, and the mods breathe all new life into it. I don't have the expansions though, so if it hits GOG with those, it's an insta-buy. Please, GOG, we WANT you to take our money!

Aug. 13, 2012
report
hide
rajones55 rajones55 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Yes, this would be an awesome addition to <a class="light_un" href="http://GOG.com" target="_blank">GOG.com</a>. Especially with the expansion packs included and the DOSBox wrappers loaded with .ogg conversions of the CD soundtracks, as pbaggers mentioned.

Jul. 3, 2012
report
hide
Strijkbout Strijkbout Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Much better than Quake 2 for some reason. If GOG gets it I hope it will be sold with the mission packs (Abyss of Pandemonium, Scourge of Armagon and Dissolution of Eternity with the soundtracks).

Jun. 24, 2012
report
hide
moritzfinck moritzfinck Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

This would be a dream come true.. I agree about having the expansion packs included. I remember playing this game to death.

Jun. 20, 2012
report
hide
pbaggers pbaggers Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Quake (the first one at least) was awesome. It would be even better if it were to be bundled with the mission packs, and the DOSBox wrappers were loaded with .ogg conversions of the excellent CD soundtracks to the game and it's expansions - which id never included in the Steam versions.

Jun. 9, 2012
report
hide
mkell_226 mkell_226 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Huh, I'm surprised there's not more noise being made for this.

Jun. 7, 2012
report
hide
vohnkar vohnkar Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

would buy this as well.

Jun. 2, 2012
report
hide
user458 user458 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

+ Mission Pack 1: Scourge of Armagon &amp; Mission Pack 2: Dissolution of Eternity With working intro and music. This is one of the most Epic FPS ever, adding this to they're list will only earn <a class="light_un" href="http://GOG.com" target="_blank">GOG.com</a> even more respect.

Apr. 15, 2012
report
hide
joe1 joe1 Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

Please note that many id software classics (not only FPS, like Doom, Quake, and Wolfenstein 3D, but also Commander Keen, etc.) are still available via their Web site. Consider, e. g., <a class="light_un" href="http://www.idsoftware.com/games/quake/quake." target="_blank">http://www.idsoftware.com/games/quake/quake.</a>

Apr. 15, 2012
report
hide
profuse profuse Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

The Steam version was terrible and it's hard to secure a legit version. The quakeworld communty is still VERY active and a release on GOG would only boost that! The most beautiful and fluid deathmatch game to have ever lived and changed gaming forever.

Apr. 8, 2012
report
hide
CaptainAppleMan CaptainAppleMan Sorry, data for given user is currently unavailable. Please, try again later. View wishlist Start conversation Invite to friendsAccept invitation Pending invitation... User since {{ user.formattedDateUserJoined }} Friends since {{ user.formattedDateUserFriended }}
Comment burried. Unhide.

I had a bucket load of problems with the Steam version, and I have yet to get my hands on a sweet boxed copy. So a GOG version would be straight up awesome!

Apr. 2, 2012
report
hide
Load more comments