My goodness, that session ran long.... way long.. just finished 15 minutes ago.

What? NFY, sure, I think she has been very pro-gangster the entire game. But TwilightBard and Adzeth were in my top 3 scum-picks. What was 'nice' about that?

I said it there, and I'll say it here: I just don't think claiming without pressure, or other extenuating circumstance, is a pro-'town' strategy in general. I think that scum should need to a work a little for their information, don't you? I have nothing against claiming, as long as there is a pro-'town' reason for doing so. If that makes me scummy in your eyes, so be it I guess.

By town, I am going to assume you mean good? Anyway as I said before I can only confirm the sister part, I would have no knowledge about that there even was another sister if it weren't for the fact that he claimed it before I confirmed it. I know what I am, and as already said is making the assumption that we're on the same team.
However I cannot state anything with certainty - its purely an assumption.

Oh and now that Vitek never guessed it for some strange reason and we're discussing Robbeasy: From what I said it should be rather obvious that the reason I also find him likely good is that he knew about the goon = vanilla - something I would only take as evidence if I knew with certainty before Random.org died that the role was goon - And therefor the obvious reason I knew that is that I myself am one (with this many claimed power-roles I doubt saying that know is any risk).

Twilightbard: In regards to that case against Adzeth I mentioned, it can be found here: http://www.gog.com/forum/general/hot_jive_at_frankies_bookstore_the_fifteenth_edition_of_gog_forum_mafia/post968

As for protecting Rob I been saying the same thing all along in that regard and I said the same about Random.org whom we know for certainty is good :)

Anyway Vitek, your point worked - though it did make me begin to suspect a certain someone when I saw that he truly was bad (referring to my "case").

I am going to make myself look stupid even if it is unnecessary, but I like to be honest so here it is:
Oh, Adzeth was scum, I haven't realized it until now. And here I was wondering what some of recent remarks mean. Great, took me only 3 days to realise it. I though we are at mylo already.

Looking at my voting record, I voted drennan/Adzeth on day one. I again voted Adzeth on day two after unvoting JMich.

Adzeth is a confirmed scum. You have lynched a confirmed good guy. You are now only scum hunting me in an attempt to try and lynch another good guy.

You are scum and must be lynched.

Ahh... so it is OMGUS then ;)?

Also note, that I haven't come after you, or anyone else, at all this Day. So, which other 'good guy' am I trying to lynch by scumhunting? Or, are you still referring to Night 3, wherein I had my vote on Adzeth, confirmed scum, for most of the time?

No big deal, I truly don't care if you vote for me or not. I'll just think your case against me has more holes in it than dear Liza's bucket.

EBWOP

Oh, I guess I did sort of go after one person today: TwilightBard. But that was just responding to a question from Vitek on whether or not I thought TB is scummy. For the record, I did, and still do, think TwilightBard is scummy. However, he is also on your scum-list, correct? So, if I am scum-hunting only to lynch good guys, as you say, and I suspect the same person as you do of being scum, which I do... then your logic must be flawed somewhere, right?

Hm, and why is that? There are 2 players left and quite small pool of available remaining players, so I would expect people to go after someone.

Because, as I said yesterday, I haven't had time to analyze the data in light of recent events (Adzeth flipping scum and GameRager flipping gangster). Adzeth was my scummiest suspect, so no real surprise there, but GameRager was my 4th most scummy pick. Part of the reason I was uneasy about GameRager is because of the overlap of the "Roleblocker" role with flubbucket. So, these results are pulling me in opposite directions in regards to flubbucket; so much so that I don't know what to think until I have had time to go through parts of the thread again.

As an aside, you say there are two 'players' left. I am assuming you mean scum? How do you know this? How do you know that there only 2 scum left? I agree that the probability is that there were three Town and now that Adzeth has been lynch there are only two left, but how do you know there isn't some independent or something? I think you might be making a bad assumption there.

Don't try this.
There were 3 scum, there is no reason why there would be different number. And even if there is neutral somewhere around, it doesn't mean anything as it clearly isn't killing role and town doesn't need to care if it lives. So there is no reason to hunt it and even if it exist no reason to account it into scum numbers.

In fact trying to start that discussion now with nothing to base in on is kinda a funny move I believe ;) Or are you Krypsyn claiming knowledge to otherwise? :D

For the record though I am very interested in what flubbucket is still, since as others have already mentioned, we know that GameRager was in fact telling the truth (personally I was fairly convinced he was a bad guy, with a choice between either flubbucket or him), hence considering flubucket a target for the lynch might not be a bad notion. I am just trying to make up my mind if the bad guys would have foreseen that and thus decided for an action to eliminate both. Hope that made sense, its late were I am at.

Action phase 2 had no kill. Gamerager (a confirmed doctor) said he protected flubbucket.
Why was no kill made, if the Doctor didn't prevent it?

Add to this list...

Vitek; Who did you Cop and what result did you get?

As for third suspect - I dont really currently have one, but I think you posted this when you were unaware we had caught Scum....;)

Flubb was the target and GR did prevent it is the most likey scenario, which gains Flubb many Gangster points.....

And what does that say for your sister's post? Since to me it reads like "Wouldn't mind lynching flub. Shall we lynch him?".
It is quite possible that Red_Baron has another theory in mind, and I'd love to hear it if that is the case.