Didn't Night Dive run into a dead end with NOLF? We just don't want to bring that painful memory back :(

I've said it before, I'll say it again:
Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain!

(supposedly in licensing hell)

Whatever's high up on the wishlist. ;) Especially games from publishers not here already. Or Amiga versions of games (or better or meaningful versions of games not already here).

I was just coming in here to post NOLF 1+2.

It's always my standard response to the "What games do you want here".

I still have both CD's, and both are playable on Linux using wine, but if they showed up here - it would still be an insta-buy.

Dark Souls
Prototype

But the question is asking for games UNLIKELY to be on GOG and I think it's likely NOLF will be eventually, despite the whole... whatever it was that made the last attempt fall through

Anyway for me I'd like to see a lot of old Japanese developed console games. Like 8 and 16 bit stuff from Nintendo, Konami, Capcom, etc.

While I get the sentiment of wanting everything in your GOG account including Blizzard Titles(I do want the early Warcraft games(up to 3) and Starcraft Series DRM free).

Blackthorne, Lost Vikings, and Rock N' Roll Racing are all free. You don't even need a battle.net account to download them. Just go to Battle.net get to the download clients page(click download battle.net app and then click classic games). They are free and while a free account is an easier way to get them you can still get to them with just a little exploration.

As far as the hard to get titles on GOG?

I want Elite Force + Expansion Pack and Elite Force 2. Heck . . . any Star Trek games are welcome. Final Unity, Starfleet Command 2, 3, Orion's Pirates, Neutral Zone mini demo, Deep Space Nine The Fallen, Star Trek Legacy, Bridge Commander. Come on GOG bring us more Star Trek find out why only Interplay has been allowed so far.

Add in Mechwarrior games(or other Mech games).

And of course expansion packs for Tom Clancy games and Rogue spear. In fact I have no idea why these are not here or why it feels like not much effort has been made to get them.

Because the deal is between interested parties (Interplay and CBS). In order for the rest of the Star Trek games to be released, the companies involved in their creation must also become interested (Paramount, Activision, Bethesda and whoever owns the rights to the Microprose Star Trek games). Just having the Interplay Star Trek games here doesn't necessarily make it easier to convince the other companies.

Not gonna add the one's already mentioned...well I'll second the Dark Souls games & Blade Runner. :)

Drakensang RPG series
Boiling Point/Xenus series
Precursors
Mirror's Edge
ParaWorld
Alpha Protocol
Rockstar games - Bully, LA Noire, GTAs
Thief (the newest one)
Tomb Raider (the recent one)

Some that have a glimmer of hope now:

Assassin's Creed 2 (and addons), 3 & 4
Far Cry 3, Blood Dragon & 4
newer Fallouts & TES series
Dishonored & addons
Call of Cthulhu Dark Corners of the Earth

I own every single game I just listed except Blade Runner & I would buy every single one of them again if thet came to gog DRM free.

As strange as it may sound, I'd actually like to see more games from already present companies that *technically* should have made things easier for GOG rather than harder, like EA, Activision and Square-Enix, for example. Lately, they seem much harder to get than new publishers.
Who knows, maybe now that Ubisoft is releasing games here again...

Square Enix did recently release Revenant, so I wouldn't consider it so unlikely.

The Mechwarrior and No One Lives Forever games.

Lucasarts


.......oh wait