grynn: Hello, I revealed the Escape Machines key on my Fanatical account just before sending it to finkleroy, so I don't really know how that happened but sorry :( I'll ask Fanatical about it.
slurredprey: Strange. No problem though. Thanks.
I got this reply, seems like this game's dev had removed all unused keys.
---
I am sorry you have duplicate keys.
I can see the order in question is very old and as such it appears the keys have been removed from Steam by the developers of the game. Because of this the game is no longer redeemable.
We provide a warranty on our keys of 30 days. A key is valid unless somebody else redeems it, or the developers of the game remove the key from Steam, both will result in a 'duplicate key' message from Steam.
If we had replacement keys available then even after this period of time we would have swapped then for you, but our spare keys have also been removed from Steam.
I am sorry but we are not able to help with getting with this problem. Please ensure you redeem any other older keys you may have. You might find that different developers haven't removed the keys from Steam and the games will still activate.
---