Killed the thread huh...
Brasas, at least 80% of the lurker lynches I have observed or participated in ended in grief and a town flip ...
Is that so far from the typical 75% town ratio?
I'm not looking at this approach as a huge upside one, just as a low downside fallback.
And by the way, I'm a keep eyes on the ball type. I look at votes. Day 1 so far is a wash pretty much...
We have a werewolf problem.
I know it, you know it, they know it, the frigging dogs know it.
So cliche though... one can hope?
I say we use the time to gather solid building materials and barricade ourselves in the Main Hall. Everyone grab an implement or two that can be used as a weapon, and any silver in the settlement. The sounds from this morning indicated there might be 3 or more werewolves about. I'd say no more than 4, though, or they'd have already been among us, enjoying a meal.
Lets set a couple of traps in the nearby woods, while we're at it.
In the RP spirit, I would not be happy to be trapped in there with Rorschach. You know what I mean? Regardless of the number... although come to think of it, do werewolves change whenever? Or just full moon? This might be a good idea afterall.
I like the traps idea though, very much. Just not sure if it actually can mean anything "in the game"...
Almost forgot, the comment about no more than 4 or else
is odd to me. What the heck do you know that I don't?
I like to imagine that a little of her spirit resides in me.
And on your left, you can see a tacit admission to having eaten poor Julie.
I decided that making a serious attempt to lynch any of the MU players on Day 1 would be poor form.
Who you got the hots for? Think of the children!
are harder to summarize, in part because I don’t think I read either particularly well. Brasas I’ve observed but don’t think I’ve played with. [She?] is also relatively new to playing with us, but I believe pretty experienced with this type of game, particularly the Resistance. Is that right?
"Pure" Mafia only played the previous one... open setup 7 players. I was surprised how many of you in observer thread thought me scummy. Resistance I'm good at yes.
You know this crowd, generally speaking, is unlikely to get off its collective rear until nightfall/deadline is staring us in the face.
I feel like I've been insulted...
I have nothing but esteem for you and wyrm >:(
Taking the opportunity, sorry I thought you were lurking when you had done one post already.
We've got a wood cutter, right? Do we have a carpenter?
I'm just the horse keeper... which come to think about it, might be good for you all to know, that there are horses available for whatever. Maybe a possee?
I mean, I'm pretty sure there's some town threat involving lynches to resolve, blah blah, but if it's wolves we're worried about, why not try to track them down during the day? That's what happened historically right? Wolves got hunted...
I'm too old. Am I too old?
To the "No Lynch" idea in 44
by Brasas... Even though Drealmer is famous for advocating no lynch, do you really think that he'd design a game where people would get rewarded for town to No Lynch just because it's something he would like to do? I like that you are at least throwing out an idea that you know will probably get you heat.
Ok. I'm writing bottoms up. I covered this on the response to Bler.
And I already said somewhere I agree with Trenton until further notice.
Liked this post but had no time to follow links. In a hurry to leave home.
snip ... want to like QuadrAlien (for making the first serious attack of the game) and want to like whoever the potato suggested a no lynch (although the reaction to it was decidedly tame compared to other sites), ... Vote: Yogsloth
Noted and Noted and Noted. And I'm not a potato :D Think of me more like a wonderful roasting location. Please.
Although perhaps that was not due to my avatar and I should feel offended :)
Events are usually not a thing on GOG. However, I'm claiming that they are a thing, in some fashion, in this particular game. I don't know the extent, but they are a thing.
You should trust absolutely everything I say, btw. I'll vouch for it.
What the heck is an event specifically?
... So I agree it's a bit odd coming from Brasas whereas from wyrm/trent/cristi it could've been more of an inside joke.
To lynch or not was discussed previous game. The positions around it framed the wagon that got Drealmer lynched by an almost all town wagon. I am still not sure if in those circunstances no lynch would have been better, and was disagreeing with Wyrm on that. And guess what - Wyrm won as scum.
Plus the flavor is all kinds of mixed signals, I thought dropping that was a good gambit to get reads.
Bottom line. I'm not as much in the group think you guys have from playing together for ages. But I listen to logic.
snip ... There's really only one thing holding me back from being willing to vote him, ...
Urgh. I'm going to give my reads since I see we're there. You always think Yog is scum Bler... and I'm the one that always keeps the powder try. Spoiler - so far no one has really struck me hard as scummy - just a bunch of day 1 posturing / probing. But to be clear, I'll vote someone.
Runnign late, this will be too short and dirty.
I had the lurkers in the frowny category >:( that means only IX now.
I have a few folks I'm curious on, no particular order:
-Quadr for the early vote - which means Nacho also pinged an echo later.
-Lift for No lynch bait reaction.
-Yog for Stanari vote.
-Wyrm for the setup pushing.
I want to like Bler and Nacho, but they can fake it. Far from cleared.
IF this was it I'd still vote Ix right now. But I expect stuff will happen.