Whoa bro chillax
I was legit pissed. Took a 50 minute walk to mostly calm down. Still kinda pissed when I sat back down, but appreciate the measured, thoughtful response. ;)
Trent's vote on cristi isn't explained at all, nor is yours. Stan's vote on cristi is barely explained. Yogs will vote cristi for whatever.
Bro I'm not even voting cristi. (Yet?)
The weird thing is trent isn't voting her either, despite ending D2 on her, and I'm pretty sure he's posted a few times since mid-day. I just kinda assumed he was.
Why are you so insistent on the disappearing kill being town?
I have no certainty that it is, but I'm penduluming off your suggestion that it "could by LYLO if the disappearer is teamed with wolves."
I mean, I come up with some unlikely probabilities, but that doesn't even make coherent sense as a possibility.
If it's 1-team their teammate kills them off? If it's two teams one team gets a whatever and the other doesn't? I mean, in both cases (RW / Brasas) it at least looks like legit scum-hunting, right? Whatever the wincon.
My intent, if there is a claim (or moreso full claim) is to try and look at how the pieces might fit in the puzzle. Maybe it's town, maybe it isn't, but I'm not going to start with the assumption it isn't given the kill pattern and flavor. And yes, trent was the benevolent SK in my game, so flavor isn't a lock.
Firstly, you need to take a deep breath and a step back. Alright.
No u. Oh wait, that's actually good advice. My bad. ;)
I mean. If it were someone else's post in question, would we be having this discussion?
Not trying to be a dick, but I think I'd have to get baked to follow that. Are you saying if you change a variable the outcome is probably different? Yes....?
Was that so hard? ;___;
Well, no. But at the time I thought we were moving towards you/cristi/nacho claiming so it seemed silly to nitpick over what might turn out to be nothing if the claims played a variety of different ways that made it moot.
But you decided to make it an issue, and nacho seems to have blown up the mass claim anyway so there wasn't any point in waiting.
(I may in fact be working an angle, but it's the "what the hell is going on in this game angle".)
I don't think that it's a stretch to infer the associative context.
Is that sufficient? I'm not entirely sure the idea of progression made it from your post into my brain.
Well, you explained why you didn't catch the "progression" mention, and sure, I assumed the D2/N2 flips were a factor, I just wanted you to walk me through, y'know, that associative context.
Do you have a case for cristi as not-wolf or not-SK (yes, I still think it's an SK) that you can remind me of? The halflife of my brain cells is...very short.
Well, the only one who's clear on SK is Tammy. Everyone else is pretty equally viable. So sure, if we're SK hunting cristi is as good a prospect as anyone. I'm not sure we're set on setup enough to just laze into that random potshotting, though. As you note, maybe it is mylo/lylo, maybe it isn't.
I only have partial notes on cristi despite having re-read her post-daybreak/pre-morning, but sure, I'll re-read and make a case tonight or more likely tomorrow. But if it's trent (or yogs) v cristi I'm picking trent pretty much every time. Nacho...who knows.
FWIW, 99% of the time I don't make notes, but I did jot a few things down reading brasas N2, and Dess D2. I think the big thing (in my memory) was that cristi's EOD1 post was basically "1 of wyrm/rw is scum" and I just don't see, even if you want to make that clear a claim, then following through and knocking off wyrm, though sure, maybe she potted quad instead.
Of course, RW didn't live any longer than wyrm's flip, so we can't PROVE she would have followed through, but she's pretty cagey as scum. I just don't see her/RW as w/w, and even if she didn't vote dess, I liked the way she handled the votecount/analysis. Of the players alive, yogs/me/cristi/trent were all not on that dess wagon. So I'm really not clear on where in any jumble of dess/brasas/lift/rw she'd fit. Trent is a bit easier to imagine.
Plus, again, the practical detail that cristi claiming is potentially also nacho claiming since one of the two is the purificatorer unless you are pulling off one hell of a bluff. So if we (collectively) were going to vote cristi to the point of claiming, just be aware it might be a 2 for 1.
Hey, I never said it was a good reason! Or that I took good notes. But you asked for a reason.