It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Look for coolers reviewed on techpowerup and you'll probably find something more than decent for your needs.
avatar
Randalator: The only way to go more silent would be water cooling with an external radiator.
I researched the subject of liquid cooling a bit. The best air cooler can be as silent as the best liquid cooler; but the liquid cooler will cool better. So relatively speaking, you're right- but in practice, you'd pick liquid cooling for better cooling not for it being quieter.

edit: I don't know if that made sense - the cooling/noise ratio when you compare them is not linear.
Post edited January 17, 2020 by teceem
avatar
gamesfreak64: Question....

Hi, i might consider an i3 ( yes it is pretty average.. compared to i7 9700k..) mainly because of cooling issues and heavy coolers needed in order to cool the hardware.

latest i5 vs latest i7 might not be that different in terms cooling , so i am curious about i3 and what the minimum hardware would be needed to keep things cool :D ( without sagging the mobo and cpu) compared to i7-9700k

Anyway, it would be nice to be able to use < 600 gram coolers to avoid sagging .... i don't like the idea of using statues or other objects to support the mobo/cpu from sagging or use a cable to support the weight like many videos show.
If you are talking about a i3 9100f, the stock cooler is enough. If you really want lower temperatures (for the peace of mind) any "tower style" cooler, with heat pipes will do just fine.
This is a freaking good CPU and IMHO, the only one that is currently better than AMD in the same range. I just wonder why there is ZERO reviews by the "mainstream benchmarkers".

The i7 9700k don't have any stock cooler and you need a good quality one, specially with overclock, wich might require liquid cooling.

Comparing cooler by it's wheight is wrong. With that said, I guess you are refering to GPU sagging, not CPU... Usually on the CPU side, when better cooling is needed, people use water cooling.
GPU sagging was a rage a few years ago, where people resort to all kind of trick, including "statues" (ahahah), nylon cord and very strog backplates. This was when AMD R9 295 was still a thing and it needed to air cool 300W+ (not personally take on AMD as nVidia had some good history as well, lol).

Miss that good old times where a RAM sticks didn't have silly rainbow lights and performance really matter!
Post edited January 17, 2020 by Dark_art_
If you not satisfied with stock cooler and want cheap and good: https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/1314300/arctic-freezer-34.html

The Core i3-9100F is indeed a fantastic value at under a hundred €uro as long as you will be using a graphics card and four cores are enough for you.
avatar
Randalator: Even an i5 has no need for a 1.2 kg monstrosity. My Macho Rev. B (880 g) with a 140 mm fan easily keeps my i5 6600K in the low fifties even under full load and in the worst summer heat.
avatar
teceem: It's not only about need. A big ass Noctua will keep a high end CPU (overclocked or not) cool enough while being relatively quiet.
Which means: it will be REALLY quiet when used to cool a low end i3 or i5. If you care about noise, higher end (heavier) air coolers will be quieter. And I just don't see how weight is relevant (to the OP). Even in the context of LAN parties - a dark rock pro 4 e.g. could withstand a lot of moving and shaking before it fell off.

I'm sure you can find some stories online about someone's heavy washing machine that fell through the floor. Is that an argument to buy the lightest crappiest washing machine you can find? Or to conclude that the weight of washing machines is generally an issue?
i like the heavy washing machine story that fell through the floor. , especially because that is one thing that would never happen to me, despite my high 'badluck factor' cause i would keep my dishwasher, heavy washing machine
and other heavy stuff on groundfloor,.

A nice sturdy floor on solid ground , cement and maybe some concrete that would be possible to fall or breakthru unless an earthquake took place, so its best to keep those machines on ground floor, this way you don't have to walk the stairs to change, if it would catch fire , it would be below on ground floor, you could easily use the top stairs to decend from the front of the house cause the fire if started by the machine would be started on groundfloor... the neighbors would also have far less noise cause usally people sleep upstairs, so its always a win only situation.


Anyway just replied cause i really like the heavy washing machine story.

avatar
gamesfreak64: Question....

Hi, i might consider an i3 ( yes it is pretty average.. compared to i7 9700k..) mainly because of cooling issues and heavy coolers needed in order to cool the hardware.

latest i5 vs latest i7 might not be that different in terms cooling , so i am curious about i3 and what the minimum hardware would be needed to keep things cool :D ( without sagging the mobo and cpu) compared to i7-9700k

Anyway, it would be nice to be able to use < 600 gram coolers to avoid sagging .... i don't like the idea of using statues or other objects to support the mobo/cpu from sagging or use a cable to support the weight like many videos show.
avatar
Dark_art_: If you are talking about a i3 9100f, the stock cooler is enough. If you really want lower temperatures (for the peace of mind) any "tower style" cooler, with heat pipes will do just fine.
This is a freaking good CPU and IMHO, the only one that is currently better than AMD in the same range. I just wonder why there is ZERO reviews by the "mainstream benchmarkers".

The i7 9700k don't have any stock cooler and you need a good quality one, specially with overclock, wich might require liquid cooling.

Comparing cooler by it's wheight is wrong. With that said, I guess you are refering to GPU sagging, not CPU... Usually on the CPU side, when better cooling is needed, people use water cooling.
GPU sagging was a rage a few years ago, where people resort to all kind of trick, including "statues" (ahahah), nylon cord and very strog backplates. This was when AMD R9 295 was still a thing and it needed to air cool 300W+ (not personally take on AMD as nVidia had some good history as well, lol).

Miss that good old times where a RAM sticks didn't have silly rainbow lights and performance really matter!
Yes i also referred to GPU sagging which is indeed far more common than CPU sagging, but CPU sagging does occur now and then, and even my huble GPU card i will buy ( and replace later when cashflow is better) migh sag indeed.

Anyway, thanks for the replies they are most helpfull
.
Post edited January 17, 2020 by gamesfreak64
avatar
gamesfreak64: Thank you for the replies ... i'm happy to read you did not had any problems at all... but sometime some people do have problems , maybe they were born to experience many problems, i consider it a case of bad luck ( bad luck is almost my middle name).
avatar
teceem: I mentioned it before: confirmation bias. On internet, often, the dissatisfied minority is a lot louder than the issue-less majority. That doesn't mean that the dissatisfied are necessarily a minority.
Try to do your research without bias; it isn't easy or low-effort. Don't ignore reviews on reputable tech sites / but don't limit yourself to one or two. A lot of Youtube reviews are click bait. User tech reviews are more often than not like taking advise from your drunk uncle at a family party. Internet as a whole in 2020 is far from the geek gathering place it used to be... a long time ago, in a galaxy far away.
ah yes, it is true "confirmation bias. On internet, often, by the dissatisfied minority ..."
you are 100% right about that, and there is lots of it more that people might think or even would expect.

Anyway ofcourse there is the 'dissatisfied minority ' which is true, they allways complain about anything that can be complained about ( many are actually quite fun to read :D)

The larger part of the people that always are right in whatever they say is also true, but there is also a very large that will never complain and or reply, so i rather be one of the minority or majority then the very large number of users that dont seem to have an opinion at all.

This is also present among voters :D well i am one of the minority / majority , depends on the topic / situation
but i do have opinions and i will vote , so its a yes or a no for me and maybe if permitted a NO votr or BLANK vote
but not to shrugs my shoulders and say i / we dont really care to vote or have an opinion at all, everyone has one except for some reason they do not want or care or maybe are just afraid to have one.
avatar
gamesfreak64: A nice sturdy floor on solid ground , cement and maybe some concrete that would be possible to fall or breakthru unless an earthquake took place, so its best to keep those machines on ground floor, this way you don't have to walk the stairs to change, if it would catch fire , it would be below on ground floor, you could easily use the top stairs to decend from the front of the house cause the fire if started by the machine would be started on groundfloor... the neighbors would also have far less noise cause usally people sleep upstairs, so its always a win only situation.
I live in an apartment and not on the ground floor. Never had an issue with the washing machine, but the downstairs neighbours sometimes complain when I'm trying to dissolve a body in the tub. :-P
avatar
teceem: It's not only about need. A big ass Noctua will keep a high end CPU (overclocked or not) cool enough while being relatively quiet.
avatar
Randalator: I have a silent build. On more than one occasion I have accidentally powered down my PC because I didn't notice that it was already running. Any noise the CPU fan might produce under load will inevitably be drowned out by what little noise the case fans and GPU fans produce.

The only way to go more silent would be water cooling with an external radiator.
Funny to mention it, once i made the same 'mistake', i had a new custom build PC and it was quiet... so wanted to start it but it was running already, normally you can adjust the button, to have it pushed long or twice to restart, shutdown the pc, seems you can set in somewhere , i heard a salesman talking about it in the PC hardware store.
avatar
gamesfreak64: A nice sturdy floor on solid ground , cement and maybe some concrete that would be possible to fall or breakthru unless an earthquake took place, so its best to keep those machines on ground floor, this way you don't have to walk the stairs to change, if it would catch fire , it would be below on ground floor, you could easily use the top stairs to decend from the front of the house cause the fire if started by the machine would be started on groundfloor... the neighbors would also have far less noise cause usally people sleep upstairs, so its always a win only situation.
avatar
teceem: I live in an apartment and not on the ground floor. Never had an issue with the washing machine, but the downstairs neighbours sometimes complain when I'm trying to dissolve a body in the tub. :-P
Sorry, didnt know that, we have many apartments in our tiny country as well, , personally i would never get used to living that high up in the clouds, born on solid ground so i'm not used to heights .

Dissolving bodies in the tub ? :D? the old lady in RED (Retired and Extremely Dangerous) movie also disolves one in a tub,i can't recall if she is on ground floor or in an apartment.
Anyway as long as the tub doesnt leak or contents spill over the tub on the floor, sipping through small cracks or openings in the floor all the way down to the neighbours, everything should be okay. :D
Post edited January 18, 2020 by gamesfreak64