dedoporno: I can't say I'm very fond of the entire martyrdom theme we have going around, but you did suggest the same in the previous game, so I'm not too surprised. Also, your specific situation somewhat allows it this time around since we may have to "take care" of you at some point just to be on the safe side. The things is we still don't
need this. A number of people believe that you are really Town, I'm not 100% sold on it, but I'm close enough to work with you while there are better options (or potential for such). I believe someone already noted that it's silly to lynch a person you actually believe is your ally hoping you'll get something out of it when there is a considerable chance you may end up getting nothing.
Basically, I implore everyone to wait for the results of the night actions before resorting to extreme measures or disclosing information that it's not required at the moment.
I agree, it's not like we can do anything till morning and the night actions come back in anyway.
But I do think we need to know what's going on. What's worrying me, is that both our lynches confessed. Why? It might have been difficult, but in RWarehall's place I would have at least tried to defend myself and stay alive...
Again with Ix, why just give up and claim scum and get lynched? I don't buy the protecting someone argument, but what if there is more to it?
What if when close to the lynch you get a PM from flub saying you can't claim, or can't claim anything other than a neutral or scum role?
I know that's highly unlikely, but I just don't understand why
both of the lynchees have confessed to anti town roles and basically committed suicide... if we had flips it wouldn't matter and we would have been given results and know what had happened, but without flips it's hard to know whether we're really two up on the scum/anti town or whether we're just being the victims of some kind of bizarre rule or power role.
I'm hoping we might have two scum teams, or at least another anti town role, and they get hit and NK'd during the night. If that happens and we get a flip, we'll know that it's method of kill that is important and be able to plan out strategies accordingly.