But the fact is that jumping on Robb and pushing for his lynch has stifled any other conversation that might have arisen and that's not good. We might end up lynching Robb just in case, but there is no need to rush into it.
I agree, while I'm not sure if Robbeasy is telling the truth or not (there are good arguments for both Scum and Town), I do think we have been overlooking the other murder. The fact is that someone killed our Coroner, and then decided to destroy any evidence we had as to how he was killed (by grinding the body up). While I am not saying we should drop the whole thing with Robbeasy, I think we should also be looking at what could have happened to DarkoD13. Without him, we lose our ability to decipher the flips, or at least find out who was and was not Town.
Also, regarding the flip, and I know this has already been discussed, but I am leaning towards only Town (and neutral) getting flipped. That would explain why RWarehall was not flipped. If he were Town, why would he have lied about being a Serial Killer. If the theory is correct, then Twilight could have also been anti-Town, and if so, that would mean that either Robbeasy is telling the truth, or he might be part of a second Mafia group or another anti-Town faction.
I am not sure Robb did false claim. What would you have done if someone visited you and then there ended up being two night kills with one being your doing from the pm saying someone visited you and you shot them? This is for anyone to answer if they feel like it. I think he had two choices if he is town - explain what happened or keep silent and hope scum comes to visit him another night. Though I can see that his timing is suspicious as he only claimed after Hijack hinted he knew about the visit.
I think if it were me, and I had thought that I killed someone, I would have come out to warn the rest of the Town. The fact that he only claimed this after Hijack made his announcement, throws some doubt on his claim. If I were an PGO, I would have little to fear by claiming my role, I would know that I was protected (even if it's only for a limited time) and that if any Scum tried to test my theory, they would get killed. Even if this mean that I was killed as well, at least I would get rid of some Scum. What I would not want was for some Town investigator getting killed by trying to see if I were telling the truth. It's a very interesting situation, one that could be used to good effect by Scum, and one that will be hard to prove for Town, unless we are willing to risk loosing one of our investigators, or if we waste a lynch on someone who may be Town.
Do you think we would all be so suspicious even if Robbeasy had not waited for Hijack's claim? Are we just using this to try to better justify our doubts, doubts we would have had anyway?
Sorry folks, I'm too tired tonight to contribute to the game. brain's refusing to focus.
That's what you get for staying up all night cutting up DarkoD13. Seriously, next time just leave the whole body, it's so much easier, and try to to eat the food while you do it next time. Nobody likes a cannibal ;-)