Posted April 06, 2015
227: Does GOG really test the patches? Wasn't Omerta broken after a bad patch (just read the reviews)? I remember reading that the same was true of the original Blackguards here after the Untold Legends DLC.
There are different kinds of tests, for different purposes. I presume GOG repackages the updated files they have received from the developers into a GOG patch installer, and sanity checks that the patch installs correctly, and doesn't appear to break the game installation. Not all developers use the same naming scheme and installers for their games and patches, so someone has to change those to "GOG format" and naming scheme anyway.
You can see the opposite in e.g. HumbleBundle where they allow the developers to use whatever format they want and HB doesn't meddle with it => the HB store is quite messy for its various kinds of DRM-free installers. GOG.com wants to be more organized with its releases, and I for one commend them for that.
I don't think GOG really play-tests the patches, ie. confirming if it really fixes all the generic gameplay issues that it is supposed to fix, and doesn't introduce new problems. I think that kind of functional testing is indeed in the hands of the developer, and GOG assumes the publisher has done their testing properly already. Apparently sometimes they don't, and in the end it is the customers who play-test the patches.
Some have suggested that if GOG required the developers to do the formatting and sanity checking for the GOG patch, and offered a more automatic way to release patches on GOG (e.g. through Galaxy), then such delays wouldn't happen. I am not quite as convinced, most publishers would most probably still prioritize the Steam patches first, and publish the GOG patches (and any other versions) only after they are done with the Steam patch.
What can GOG.com do in a situation like that? Sue the developers for prioritizing Steam over them? That still wouldn't speed up the release of the GOG patch. At least when GOG decides to prepare and sanity check the GOG patch themselves, they are taking matters in their own hands, instead of waiting when (if ever) the developers finally release a fully tested and sanity checked GOG patch.
Post edited April 06, 2015 by timppu