Leucius: The only thing that turns me off about Eldritch (if it's the right game I'm remembering) is the 90's graphics. I hate to be a graphics snob, but... idk.
It's a deliberate stylistic choice by the devs, but yes, that doesn't mean you have to like it. :)
I was dubious about the graphics myself at first. But as I played through I actually found that they accent the creepiness of the game. The sound works very well in making you uncomfortable, and having these almost cartoonish beings pursue you gradually becomes something you dread. The immersiveness of the game, and the tension of navigating the claustrophobic spaces, ultimately make the game better than the sum of its parts.