[...] No. It is made by cherub faced hillbilly children in the rolling hills of Kentucky. [...]
Yeah well, I didn't really expect you to fess up.
[...] Why didn't you hammer (or vote) Bookwyrm627??
Now that's an interesting question. I'm trying to solve this so we lynch scum Today. What about you? Were you looking to get Bookwyrm627 lynched without getting your hands dirty, while being able to point a finger at me if he flips town?
I did try to look at others, more than once. No one else showed interest (mchack stayed focused, the other masons kept their heads down, and the people in question were being accused of being possible scum), and the first claimed mason actively fought against my effort to look at a wider range of people. [...]
I'm talking about Today, after the remaining Masons stepped forward. But you didn't, even though, as I already said, your post #1244 scenario arguments don't exclude them.
[...] Considering how Trent has mostly been just following the masons, and Flub has been floating, I don't have much else to say about either of them. Do you? [...]
Now that we know for a fact that neither of them is a Mason, I'm trying to see if and how things may fit, the mostly following the Masons and floating included. You could try and do the same, if you're town.
[...] II'm currently pointing the finger at you because I think you are the best answer to the question "Why did Adalia die on N3?"
Do you? You were inclined to vote me two days ago, as early as post #1226, with a maybe for flubbucket, while trentonlf and ZFR were to follow. No reasons, no arguments. Not for your vote, not for your intended votes, nor for the order of them. You only came up with your alternative scenario after gogtrial34987 presented the case on you, and your initial defence didn't bear any fruits.
[...] If Adalia and I were scum buddies on Day 2, then there were enough votes to lynch you if everyone from Day 1 rejoined your wagon and there wouldn't be any reason for me to try and open the field to consider other players (name the masons). [...]
The thing is that when you came on, adaliabooks was the leading wagon, and nothing (much) was happening - Leonard03's L-1 wagon had already died down, and my wagon didn't start to form until quite late in the Day - and you're not one to sit and wait for things to unfold, so opening the field and putting Leonard03 back at L-3 while sticking to your town-read on me was quite inline, and worked out just fine in the end.
[...] If Hunter and Adalia were buddies, then why would Adalia have a conversion on N3, or did a cyborg kill him?
If adaliabooks died failing a conversion, then he obviously had a shot, which means that in this case, Hunter65536 attempted the N1 conversion, which in turn brings us to mchack's assessment of how things went down N1. Same if you and adaliabooks were the original Mutant team.
If he didn't die that way, then someone must have killed him. Or did he commit suicide?
Since you're not cleared in any way and (some) things fit, I find it prudent to keep you in the list of suspects, including the case of being aligned with the Mutant team, while I'm trying to figure things out. Which in turn means that it's not (yet?) a given that you've been, and are, truthful in everything you've said, and are saying.
You're doing the same with me. I'm extending it to all the non-Masons players too, while you are not.
[...] Leonard was on my willing to vote list and he had made his case as to why he wasn't scum earlier in the day [...]
Yes, I know, it's just that you made a point that I didn't post my suspects when I thought I had been lynched, but shortly afterwards you didn't give him a chance to do it. I went back and checked, and he hadn't posted earlier in the Day the thoughts and names he did after the mod declared his lynch and Night-fall. What if he hadn't made that post? Weren't you interested in hearing what he had to say?
[...] I don't think flub was an original scum [...]
What makes you think he wasn't?
[...] the chances are high that he was recruited N1 as he was a safer target than anyone else, [...]
Wouldn't you say the same if it's you who got converted N1?
[...] my gut says HSL is the last scum. What do you think?
I'll tell you what I know - your gut's been wrong since the beginning, and you'll see it soon enough.
[...] Flub was telling the truth all along. [...]
Did you look into him?
I was pondering about him being the N1 Convert. You said you have a certain mental model of how adaliabooks operates, but what if he did the opposite of what was expected of him? After all, he did up his scum play noticeably this game. If adaliabooks considered that mchack's focus on 3 specific players and insistence to leave flubbucket alone may be enough to keep him out of immediate lynch-danger D2, his team may have gone with him. And with everything else that transpired on D2 and him floating, nobody really took another look at flubbucket. Krypsyn turned things upside down on D3, and now here we are.
Having said all that, I see that gogtrial34987 put me at L-1. And since I'm going to be quite busy myself tomorrow, we might as well end the Day here. Vote HypersomniacLive