[...] I find it interesting that most of mchack's arguments are about himself living or dying. [...] Mchack... his arguments seem to go in circles and often seem to make unexplained logic leaps and assumptions. I am not sure it is indicative of alignment, but it comes off as a bit scummy to me (did Day 1 as well). [...]
They do, don't they?
[...] 1 scum dead [...]
And you think he was scum from the beginning?
[...] people willing to lynch a townie
yesterday (flubs + trent) [...] only reason I can think of
is you fearing he may flip scum and trying hard to not let this happen. [...]
I thought we agreed Yesterday that you're smarter than you want us to think, and pay attention more than you let on. Makes me wonder...
[...] or sage (who wyrm also tried for in the end) [...]
And Hunter65536 promptly followed him. What do you make of that?
or anyone else may be converted. [...]
Which could well have been you, if you were town D1 as you claimed, couldn't it? So, why should anyone take your word that you're town Today, and follow your suggestion?
Also, since anyone
else could have been converted, how are you going to tell if someone's flip Today is the same as the one they'd have flipped Yesterday?
[...] (hunters, which was most likely unsuccessful in recruiting
I was going to ask you what makes you so sure that he died trying to convert someone, but see that Bookwyrm627 already did.
[...] lynching the most suspected scum from last day is even more rewarding as if we lynch correctly we not only kill scum but also the last remaining conversion shot of that team dies
And you're so über-confident about that because...?
[...] uh, nope all of scum were on my wagon [...]
Are you saying that every single scum put all their eggs in one basket? If so, why would they?
[...] You didn't talk to hunter as if you thought him scum. I at least offered him a place on my list (your spot in fact)
And that makes you automatically town how exactly? Let's assume that it normally would (it wouldn't), does having two scum teams in play change anything?
[...] I explained in my last post. Adalia or HSL flipping scum this morning would not at all help in lynching me. that's why I assume they didn't do the conversion shots themselves. [...]
Again, do you factor in the fact we don't have a single scum team?
[...] Also, just as a reference (and blatantly stolen from Krypsyn's Unofficial vote counts, so if something's missing, blame him). On Day 1 Hunter voted for: flubbucket, Bookwyrm (when Bookwyrm asked for the votes), trentonlf, adaliabooks (RVS), mchack, and HypersomniacLive. [...]
Not sure I follow, a reference to what exactly?
Well, what we saw from him for most of yesterday. Today he seems to be playing a little more fast and loose, a bit less serious. Which I don't particularly ever remember him doing so, it could well be the sign of someone who has been converted and doesn't know how to behave.
More likely aiming for lots of WIFOM as to whether he was or wasn't converted, I'd say, especially after his promise, and the way it affected the game state Yesterday. I don't think that "not knowing how to behave" if he was converted is all that applicable to trentonlf.