RWarehall: If you want to know why I'm focused on Cristigale, look at posts 230 and 231. These are the firsts posts in the game that smell really scummy to me.
Wow, RWarehall ignores what I've said about drealmer. And keeps twisting/exaggerating to fit his purpose. Let's run through this to see it in action...
(emphasis added throughout)
RWarehall: The arguments in 230 seem twisted to pass shade.
Implications that this wagon is necessarily scummy even going so far as to claim that no fast lynch means its a bad wagon and scum just has to be on it. And this is the part where I am noting the complete absence of consideration on how Drealmer fits into the equation.
No, I didn't imply or claim the wagon itself had to be scummy, this is what I said: "Gamma is at L-2 and still alive. That suggest to me that either Gamma or one of the players on his wagon are scum." I said either/or and included Gamma in my possible scum pairs.
RWarehall: The arguments in 230 seem twisted to pass shade. Implications that this wagon is necessarily scummy even going so far as to claim that no fast lynch means its a bad wagon and scum just has to be on it. And this is the part where I am
noting the complete absence of consideration on how Drealmer fits into the equation. I addressed this in my first reply, but RWarehall chose to ignore it. I stated my assumptions in 230, specifically I said: "assuming a 2 player scum team still remains". That implies that I am assuming drealmer was town. Which is not a "complete absence of consideration".
In my first reply, I also linked to my initial position on drealmer: "We don't know drealmer's alignment. I think scum-drealmer would have been more involved. My guess is that drealmer was town. If he was scum, we are in a better position, but I don't think we should bank on that." I was not considering options where drealmer is scum because I think it is unlikely and it's a risk to play that way. RWarehall made a similar observation (a mathematical take on the risk involved)
here.
RWarehall: Then post 231, the same issue again ignoring the possibility the Drealmer might be scum. I very WIFOMy list of "all" scum pairs (note the lack of Drealmer possibly being scum. And again a directed attack based on some very arbitrary parameters.
Post 231 I started with this: "Following from my last post, " I am continuing with the thoughts/positions from post 230. Given the assumptions, there is no reason to mention drealmer.
RWarehall: Then post 231, the same issue again ignoring the possibility the Drealmer might be scum. I very WIFOMy list of "all" scum pairs
(note the lack of Drealmer possibly being scum. And again a directed attack based on some very arbitrary parameters.
Golly, he's intent on driving this drealmer point home. My previous comment still applies.
RWarehall: Then post 231, the same issue again ignoring the possibility the Drealmer might be scum. I very WIFOMy list of "all" scum pairs (note the lack of Drealmer possibly being scum.
And again a directed attack based on some very arbitrary parameters. @Rwarehall - Where was the
first "directed attack"? I don't see it mentioned. And what are the " very arbitrary parameters"?
RWarehall: Even Cristi's play I might lean a little towny in other games, but those two posts and
just the general directed kamakase attacks on players all game are the scummiest things I see in the game.
@RWarehall - So, I assume that you consider my vote on Bookwyrm a "kamakase attack". Where else have I done this? What other player(s)? All game??
Also, please answer this earlier question from your vote: (I added the first part of the paragraph back in to make it easier to identify)
RWarehall: I've seen posts like #231 before. Look busy, look townly. Also conveniently leaving out the possibility Drealmer was scum.
And the tin foil hat conspiracy theory that I planned the whole thing out to create that fast mislynch... cristigale: WTH? Where did I say anything like that??
This is a complete fabrication. I never said anything close to that.
Vote RWarehall There may be some OMGUS to this, but I'm not sure how else to read it. I'm not sure who his partner is (wouldn't it be ironic if it was drealmer, I still doubt it).