It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
GammaEmerald: At this point I believe the scumteam is you and one of mich or wyrm. I really really don't like you asking about whether the shock could be faked while townreading Christi. Suggests fishing for a way to walk that one back,
I noted your analysis since it was the first thing I reallyvnoticed this game day. Point out where other people said what you did?
avatar
cristigale: I like the case that Sage made on Gamma. Not posting his 'lost' post looks scummier the longer it continues. If you had a case, it shouldn't be that hard to recreate it.

@gamma - we are still waiting for that post.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: You question Sage about her reading of you. I've reread your reads list, and Sage is pretty close. You "kinda" agree with me that JMich seems scummy, you read Dessimu as scum, and the closest to a null read would be on RW (where you're going to "wait and see"). There is very little to back up your reads at any point.
I never said I thought cristi was faking anything. I asked you a question. You are twisting my words.
*****************************************************
You trudge on through the swamp and finally reach it's rim. But it doesn't get better. The next area to cross will be the red forest. The rain has finally stopped at least and the clouds part to reveal a beautiful, fiery sunset. In front of you the red trees stand like a warning. The wetness of the rain and the red evening light make it look as if the trees are bleeding and yet, for all the menacing sub-tones, the Red Forest also has it's own enchanted charm. It could even look pretty, if you didn't know that it is saturated with radioactive patches and dangerous monsters. But, with major anomalies blocking all other paths, this cursed forest is the path you must take.
******************************************************
Attachments:
Glad to see Sunday was active. I am done with holiday stuff and catching up.
avatar
GammaEmerald: Alright that makes sense. I'd like his input on this matter now.
Still not confessing because I have nothing to hide. Really and truly.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: I think you've been pretty erratic, and distinctly not helpful to town all game.

Would I prefer to hit Scum over NS? Yes, yes I would. Would I be willing to take a NS over a Town? In a heartbeat, especially in a MyLo situation. Scum can coerce an NS to vote with them.

I agree with RW about your focus on "Hunt scum not NS!" It kind of sounds like you're an NS, or at least want to be read that way.
I don't get the push back from either here or from RWarehall on Gamma's comment about a NS. If we are in MYLO, then we lose if we lynch a NS (apart from well-played NA) assuming a 2 player scum team still remains. I don't see how we have the leeway of lynching a NS today.

Gamma is at L-2 and still alive. That suggest to me that either Gamma or one of the players on his wagon are scum. Sage is the only player that I am fairly confident is town. Which leaves Gamma or RWarehall. I find it unlikely that RWarehall busing his buddy in this case. Which leaves the remaining part of the scum team in JMich/Bookwyrm.

Going to get some lunch while I think about possible pairs.
Following from my last post,

If there is scum between Gamma/RWarehall and JMich/Bookwyrm, who is a possible team?

First, I find it unlikely that JMich/Bookwyrm are a team. If this is an act, color me impressed.

Which leaves:
Gamma/JMich
Gamma/Bookwyrm
RWarehall/JMich
Rwarehall/Bookwyrm

Of those, RWarehall has defended both Bookwyrm and JMich. Gamma is the only living player he has pushed. I'm not sure what to make of that. Neither Bookwyrm or JMich have said much to RWarehall. Bookwyrm did seem to prod RWarehall to contribute and discussed JMich. I don't see any interaction between JMich/RWarehall.

Bookwyrm has expressed suspicion towards Gamma and willingness to vote him. He has not voted for Gamma. This could be distancing, but looking at the context/timing, it doesn't seem fake. This is probably my least likely pair.

Gamma/JMich - No direct interaction that I noticed. Gamma did lean JMich slightly scummy and asked trent for a read on him.

I chuckled at Bookwrym's last post, but he's got a point. I'd like to hear JMich's repsonse.

TLDR - my guess is the scum team is one of the following:

Gamma/JMich
RWarehall/JMich
Rwarehall/Bookwyrm

@anyone - thoughts?
Bueller? ..... Bueller? ..... Bueller?



Guess I'll check back later.
Did some major malady strike the strike team? Where did everyone disappear to?
@christi I really don't think RW is scum with how he backed off of me. I can get a scumread of both of us, but reading him as scum and not me is fairly foolish.
Who do you think is scum on the Dessimu wagon if anyone? Which votes are you not impressed by on that wagon?
avatar
GammaEmerald: Bookwyrm I still feel is town who has righteous indignation, even though it isn't right
When did I go from scum to town in your eyes? And how does that gel with the following statement?

avatar
GammaEmerald: At this point I believe the scumteam is you and one of mich or wyrm.
Gamma, am I town or am I scum?

-----

avatar
cristigale: @anyone - thoughts?
One thing that bothered me from end of Day 1 is how fast that jump to Dessimu got running. RW starts the wagon, Gamma hops on very soon after, then Sage, and then me and Cristi cap him.

Before I go any further, I'm not claiming innocence in that lynch.

I'd initially been suspicious of RW and Gamma as a pair, considering how fast they got it started. When I look back at the posting, I see that Gamma WOULD have started the wagon if he hasn't screwed up his previous attempt to vote Dess, so he doesn't look nearly so bad with regard to his Dess vote. Looking back, RW starting the wagon is the first time he's made any mention or taken notice of Dess. At all. Leaves me wondering if he saw enough interest that scum!RW figured he'd get an easy lynch near Night, and who'd guess that scum started the wagon? I'd already expressed my agreement with a Dess lynch, Gamma had actively (tried) to vote him, and RW just kicked it off with "I like what Cristi said".
Do you really think when I ISO Dess and see a lot of Russian this or that, I wouldn't find him a little scummy? C'mon.
And heck, strange how my starting a wagon somehow has become how I had some masterplan to induce you and Christie to quick hammer. I guess I'm just that good...

Dess mostly was speaking Russian and not saying much. I voted to provide pressure. I didn't screw up that pressure preventing Dess from giving us something serious to judge it on.
Let's make Cristigale happy and get Gamma off the brink.

Unvote Gamma

I've seen posts like #231 before. Look busy, look townly. Also conveniently leaving out the possibility Drealmer was scum. And the tin foil hat conspiracy theory that I planned the whole thing out to create that fast mislynch...

Vote Cristigale

I've noted Trent's suggestion of an all girl team, I sure don't see anything wrong with Sage's posts, but I don't get the same feel from Cristigale.
avatar
GammaEmerald: Bookwyrm I still feel is town who has righteous indignation, even though it isn't right
avatar
Bookwyrm627: When did I go from scum to town in your eyes? And how does that gel with the following statement?

avatar
GammaEmerald: At this point I believe the scumteam is you and one of mich or wyrm.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Gamma, am I town or am I scum?

-----

avatar
cristigale: @anyone - thoughts?
avatar
Bookwyrm627: One thing that bothered me from end of Day 1 is how fast that jump to Dessimu got running. RW starts the wagon, Gamma hops on very soon after, then Sage, and then me and Cristi cap him.

Before I go any further, I'm not claiming innocence in that lynch.

I'd initially been suspicious of RW and Gamma as a pair, considering how fast they got it started. When I look back at the posting, I see that Gamma WOULD have started the wagon if he hasn't screwed up his previous attempt to vote Dess, so he doesn't look nearly so bad with regard to his Dess vote. Looking back, RW starting the wagon is the first time he's made any mention or taken notice of Dess. At all. Leaves me wondering if he saw enough interest that scum!RW figured he'd get an easy lynch near Night, and who'd guess that scum started the wagon? I'd already expressed my agreement with a Dess lynch, Gamma had actively (tried) to vote him, and RW just kicked it off with "I like what Cristi said".
I know when I read you as Town but not how specifically so I'll go back for that
I am like 70 percent certain you are Town
VLA until Thursday
Don't miss this Lift
Was away most of yesterday, catching up now. Let me see what happened.
avatar
GammaEmerald: As I said, nothing to confess. Vanilla Townie.
Small question here. Are you giving your role name (as the capitalization would imply) or a description of your role?

@Wyrm. Quite a bit of back and forth, the ones that should bear a bit more scrutiny are the ones on Dessimu's wagon. Gamma was the first one to move that way, though unsuccessfully, RW was the first one actually on it, then we have Sage, you and Cristi. It does feel like a "Let's save wyrm" wagon, though it could also be a case of "I don't think wyrm is scum".

In addition, I do not think drealmer had a role. No idea about his alignment though.
avatar
GammaEmerald: As I said, nothing to confess. Vanilla Townie.
avatar
JMich: Small question here. Are you giving your role name (as the capitalization would imply) or a description of your role?

@Wyrm. Quite a bit of back and forth, the ones that should bear a bit more scrutiny are the ones on Dessimu's wagon. Gamma was the first one to move that way, though unsuccessfully, RW was the first one actually on it, then we have Sage, you and Cristi. It does feel like a "Let's save wyrm" wagon, though it could also be a case of "I don't think wyrm is scum".

In addition, I do not think drealmer had a role. No idea about his alignment though.
Just a summary of what I saw in my role pm
I could be a PR and have no idea tbh