I have Hijack as town. I believe yogsloth, agent, and you are town. I know I'm town so that leaves JMich and CSPVG, that's why I asked your impression of them.

Unvote JMich

Because 5 votes on him out of the bat is ridiculous. Not sure if there was any skipped NK, but I buy JMich's claim.

CSPVG returned Vanilla upon role cop shot. No Cult Leader there, though that doesn't mean he is not scum or cultist, if there's a cult.

Anyone can explain to me why agent is confirmed town? He is confirmed triple voter and that's about it. The way he jumped gun to vote JMich 3 times makes me suspicious.

So you would suggest that I don't use my power? What else am I supposed to do, vote for three different people? That kind of defeats the purpose...
So I vote for the person I feel most likely I scum. I know I can't trigger majority lynch, so I'm using my power to the best of my ability.


Also, why would everyone have assumed that JOAT had a roleblock? I mean, it's not exactly typical to have a daykill, is it?

It's pretty standard to have a vigilante shot. The fact it was a day power was just flub putting a spin to it.

I
I
\/

That's not actually in the OP, hence my not seeing it. Sorry. I suppose I should have read the signup thread more closely.

So, this is where I'm at:

1. If you want to off me, go ahead. It would be better than getting a power role (I really am Town Vanilla), but slightly worse than offing an actual Mafia/Cult player (if the latter does indeed exist).

2. I don't know if I believe there's a Cult or not. At one point, I thought maybe yogsloth or HijacK would have taken it, just so they could say they won as a Cult Leader (Note: This is not a slight towards either of you, it would be a rather cool thing to do), but I've began to doubt myself on both accounts: I now don't think yogsloth would pick it - out of simply courtesy - and obviously HijacK is a JOAT (or some variation there on).

Apart from the two people listed above, I don't really see anyone else going for it.

3. Moving on, I would really only be willing to vote for agent, Vitek, trentonlf, or JMich at this point.

JMich is also a possibility, but he claimed Cop and has been so quiet this game (yes, I know, the irony, etc.) that I don't know whether to off him for it or if he's just been doing his usual JMich routine.

Vitek has been Vitek. He's been helpful in certain instances, but I played a game with him so long ago that I'm not really sure what to look out for. I'll put him down as my least likely to vote for, at least for now.

Trentonlf has also, largely, been what I would have expected from trenton, and I don't have anything that I could really point towards - other than his claim (but then we get into a glass houses situation) - to say, "Yes, he was really scummy here, we should off him for it." So, I have a gut feeling that he may be scum. For now, I won't place a vote on him.

Lastly, agentcarr/AFP seemed suspect to me on D1, but I acknowledge that it would have been, at the very least, unkind to off agent on D1 after he replaced AFP. He, again, hasn't done anything, but for voting JMich three times, which I can point towards to say that we should off him, but I feel he's scummy.

---

In closing: I say we sit here looking at one another until the deadline is upon us before rushing to off someone. It's the GOG way. Also, I'll most likely have to skim read back through the thread to see if I find anything of interest.

TIME FOR TIMER

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20160418T18&p0=70&msg=End+of+Day+Three&font=sanserif&csz=1

Enh.

Vote trentonlf

btw, I am now into the second act of this.

I love it.

No longer willing to vote JMich. I'd rather go for CSP or agent, tho if push comes to shove I'll go for trent.

I am still trying to figure out who to vote.
If we were to go after CL it could only be trenton, CSPVG or JMich.
I would rather thought there is mafia alive instead and went after it. There we can't 100% discount based on roles anyone but I am not going to vote yogsloth nor HijacK so it leaves me again with the same three people + agentcarr.
If I am counting right, we can lynch 2 people safely and third has to be hit, right?
If it is the case I would go after someone else than JMich, let him investigate (if he is indeed cop, there is noone to verify it now), if he finds mafia, lynch that person, in case it was lie lynch him last Day. If he doesn't find mafia, I would most likely lynch him, but it depends and in case it's still not over, there will be 50% chance of getting the right one on the last Day.
Who I would prefer to kill is agentcarr only for his role, because we just can't allow possible mafia with 3 votes.
Otherwise I would probably go with CSPVG over trent but there is not really difference and I don't care much.

The way it stands: we are 7 players and agent has 3 votes. If we account for lynch (someone but him) and no NK, he will most likely be quadruple voter or some shit, or maybe still triple, depending how the role works, but he will still have 3 votes. If he gains one more vote after tonight, and we have both a lynch and an NK, we are about 7 left and he alone will have 4 votes.

Out of 10 possible votes in the game with his, that's 40% vote power. Not sure about you, but I'm not OK with it. His role has been verified, but alignment has not. If we let him alive for JMich to investigate him, he or whomever is left as mafia may off JMich on the off chance he is not mafia, and thus drive more confusion. What we do today I think will be crucial towards the following days. So the question is, who do we lynch?

@trenton, JMich, agent, CSPVG, how would you proceed and who you think should be lynched Today and why?

I may be reading too much into my PM (will receive target's alignment, not town/non-town result), but I'd be more comfortable going after one of the 3 vanillas instead of any verified role (which mostly means agentcarr16, since HijacK was town on Night 1).
I will reluctantly go after agentcarr16 if you think mafia is a better possibility than CL though.