jamesjeb: Gold Box - I personally found the Krynn series to be better than the Pools series. I thought they had a more interesting story and better used their setting. I would rate the series as: Krynn, Pools, Savage Frontier, Buck Rogers. After checking out some of the original games it may be worth your time to check out Unlimited Adventures.
Repent! I dare you, repent or you will suffer for Eternity in hell!
How dare of you to put Buck Rogers last! Just because it was the only D&D ever in Space (at this time) it already deserves first place, it was genre-breaking (me thinks ;) )
But the beauty with the old games, I think, there were more choices and always a game/genre for every taste.
Nowadays I find that too much effort is put into the graphics and not enough into the gameplay/story (yes there are exceptions).
I somewhere read an interesting article of Lord British about his Ultima-Series and yes you can see his different ideas reflected in his games (working of memory here and sorry no link). Same true for some other classic me thinks.
Why do I bring it up (again^^), quite easy it all just depends on your taste which one too choose. But I also think that the replay value of the older games is a wee bit higher. Yes due to HW-limitations they were far more linear, but due too the far more randomness like in battle or similar every game plays a wee bit different. One example being Buck Rogers, trying to fight against the pirate boss comes there to my mind ;) .
Just think of Diabolo, yes nice RPG (I liked to play it), but haven't really replayed it since, sometimes I do feel a wee bit like replaying, but .......I don't know.
To be really frankly, I think those oldies all deserve to be played again (and again and again......) ;)
dtgreene: cRPG and similar
oh and dtgreene, just as a side note, would be good, if you already give such a (really) good overview, could you refrain from using those abbreviation, please ;) (reaaly had to think hard about some of those or at least write them out :D)
and
for me there are only RPGs in the old days, this classification is rather new only so hence, IMHO, shall not be applied backwards, or?