All critics occasionally wield their status as critics to tear into the games they find too difficult. Yahtzee (whom I like very much) had an epic ragequit in both Witcher and Witcher 2.
Them's the breaks.
Critic doesn't need to love the game, but he HAS to be FAIR...and this prick obvieously underrated TW2. I understand 7/10 - someone doesn't like Witcher lore, but he has to give such a score because of visuals, sound, and storyline( these 3 are undoubtedly game's pros)
Other critic fell in love with the lore and gave the game 9 or even 9.5. No matter how you hate Geralt, his world and CDPR...score less than 6.5 - 7 is just ridiculous.