All of the guides and walkthroughs are agreed that the instructions Twillen gives for placing the statuettes are wrong, and give the supposed correct order. But the game does not give you a choice: when you click the pedestal, it chooses what statuette to place, and they are NOT the same as the ones given in the guides.

It will be awhile before I complete this quest, but I'm going to go ahead and try it and see what happens. Maybe this is a "feature" of the 1.10 patch, we'll see.

-- Mal

I'm pretty sure that when you click a pedestal it automatically chooses the right statuette.