The one I'd like to play the most right now is Gothic. The ones I'd definitely want to play in the future are Enclave and Commandos 2+3. And, with the new release Anachronox is also in my wishlist. Now, I have heard good things about Anachronox, so I'd want to give it a try, but not sure if you count this out of idle interest or not.
EDIT: oh, and I'm mid 30s.
Post edited March 15, 2012 by tarangwydion