I just recently found out about this thread, but it seems like an awesome idea. I wish I could purchase a few titles which were released recently on GOG, but I probably wouldnt be able anytime soon... I hope for a little discount at some point, but before that I thought to try my luck :/
My current wishlist is:
Tomb Raider 1+2+3 - awesome package, these were literally the first PC games I have ever played! Nearly screamed when they announced they will be added to the GOG catalogue.
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver - have heard only awesome things about the series, but never got the chance to try it. Adventures in this mood are always appreciated, I hope for the best for the game!
Myst 5: End of Ages - one of the most smart and imaginative worlds I have found were in Myst games. Have never played this one, though, so I cannot wait to lay my hands on a copy of it some day.
Heroes of Might and Magic 3 Complete - a classic in the genre, have spent countless hours on it as a kid playing its vast scenarious.
Legend of Grimrock - a new game, multiple friends have recommended it. It does sound interesting, hopfully I will try it some day.
Dreamfall: The Longest Journey - an adventure I seem to have missed. Was recommended multiple times, even recently. I hope it is indeed as good as everyone says!
This is it I think, would be a hundred times thankful if there is a generous soul out there who could help out with some title. Thanks a bunch to the great community! :)