Can be seen as both ways, townish or scummy. Usually later into the game people see info sharing (while assuming it is genuine) as a town thing to do, unless of course you have a grand scheme they have no idea about. But this early into the game it looks like fishing for bonus credo points to me, which is a lot less townish to put it bluntly, if at all.

Still, it is to be expected to see someone per game play like that. Mrkgnao had a way of gaining credo points early on. Gonna advise you from now, when you play with him, never believe a damn thing 100%, no matter what others say. He knows how to sugar coat things better than anyone I've seen, and I've been places.

RWarehall is doing what I would do in his situation. A target is on his back for winning a "fabulous" prize, I would do what I could to make the target smaller. He is presenting his prize as almost inconsequential so focus will not be on the fact that he has a prize. I also believe him. He is getting scrutinized as being scummy for his actions so far, but I don't see that.

I'm not sure if all the prizes were the same or not, no one playing the game knows unless Flub shared that info with the prize winners. Whatever the prizes are I'm sure we'll find out in due time, but as I said earlier focusing on them is not what we should be doing. What we should be doing is trying to find the scum.

Have fun waiting for a game with 18 players where there is a doc and that doc miraculously stops every NK. I'm gonna say it again, yes, there is the possibility of a doc to miraculously do that, but I don't put my money on such inefficient odds. It's like betting on the 0 when playing roulette. How many do actually win from doing that?

I see it as an over-play of one’s hand to try and grab town points. This post immediately struck me. To come out and push (firmly, disguised with gentle words like “very slightly”) for town points for all prize winners is to very directly attempt to gain credit as Town for something obviously irrelevant. A noob might do that; I simply don’t buy it from a veteran. In fact, he turns it around that those who didn’t “try” hard enough must be scum. This:

…is just way out of tune.

Then he keeps repeating the point. Yep, this is definitely where my gut is right now.

I don't find this very convincing. More so because of the fact what he does is basically forcing us to have him in a good light for literally no good reason other than the fact he won a prize. I'm sorry, what? That smells fishy to me.

Post 596
I am guessing this is the part where you say he is forcing us to see him in a positive light:
So frankly. forget the odds, I think any winners and even some of the others who tried hard to win, I'm leaning very slightly to town. Scum, I think, would be making a very silly mistake joining the limelight, but hey, always the possibility of a greedy short-sighted scum or a rather vanilla one looking for a power boost. The serious roles whether its a Godfather or Serial Killer or whatever craziness Flub has in store are highly unlikely to be among the prize winners (or people who may have posted 100 surnames). Personally, I'm going to look harder at those who didn't try to win a prize. Why? And what are they trying to protect?

If so I'm not sure how "leaning very slightly to town" is forcing us to see him in a good light.

I'm not disputing your opinion, it could be spot on. But I don't see it that way.

What? I'm simply saying that trying to guess the setup with no information is like firing into the dark. You don't know what you're hitting, or IF you're hitting anything. We have no information about how this is set up and I'm sure that Flubb has a few curveballs in the mix as well. In fact, the only people who might have information are the people that we want to hunt, the Mafia. Better to scumhunt then spend too much time contemplating with no evidence.

I was actually discussing the potential of chances town has to be mistaken, because I was called bad at math apparently from a discussion where I was explaining how a "likely" thing doesn't mean it's true. I was the "likely" candidate for scum 3 times past and it was never the truth.

But we digress. This discussion reached an unneeded point since I am not actually willing to discuss the setting of this game right now. Day 1 is simply too obscure. Let's re-open this subject on Day 2.

I've quickly scanned through the posts and am now trying to read through them more carefully. How long has it been since Crewdroog's last post?

If I am correct and did not miss one after this it is listed as 2 days ago.

http://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_mafia_25_terror_at_tres_leches/post473

I hope all is well with Crew, she has not been on Steam either

I got a message saying she has the flu.

I encouraged her to liberally apply adult beverages and get plenty of sleep. We would be waiting patiently here for her return.

Not good that she has the flu but good to know she is ok other than that. I found it very unlike her to not be on at all. I hope she takes your advice and rests up. Health is always more important. Feel better Crew!

While all of us feel bad about this and everyone encourages her to rest and heal, can we receive a replacement if 8 or 9 days of inactivity are reached? By not contributing with anything, she's in a similar position with Quadralien in game 23, and we all know what his alignment was.