We never had solid confirmation that RWarehall was a restrictor, I just assumed that the mention's in flubs flavour post (of tape etc.) might have been a confirmation of his role. But it may just have been that the flavour post was made up from our interactions through out the day.

At the time I saw ddickinson's slips as being genuine slips rather than just newbie mistakes and as such had her as prime target. But I'm not so sure now as some of the things she said in her defence have given her some town points for me.

And with that said here's what I've been thinking:

WARNING: Wall of text approaching!

So I've been reconsidering the situation and come up with a few ideas.

I haven't got a solid read on anyone really. My various candidates for being scum have in some way knocked my judgement so I'm taking a different approach.

Basically I'm going to look at two things and see where they get us, role claims and night actions. (there will be quite a few assumpitions made here, nothing is fact or solid evidence, just my logical conclusions based on the evidence available)

Let's start with Yogs. Right now there are two things that I see supporting his claim. One somewhat trivial and subjective, the other not. The first is his response to the lack of flip and his attitude since. As scum would presumably not be bothered by a lack of flips this reaction is less likely from scum, and if it is an act for this very purpose it's masterfully done. The second is CSPVGs claim and read.

So lets look at CSPVG. If Yogs were scum that would have to make CSPVG scum as well or naive. Now if Yogs were scum and CSPVG naive that would mean we have no actual town cops, or at least no counter claims. This seems unlikely, while it's possible we have a cop sitting on his counter claim to not draw attention and muddy the waters I'm discounting this for the moment, as scum deciding to claim not one but two cop roles knowing there would likely be a real town cop seems a very dangerous ploy. Ditto for CSPVG being scum. So it looks likely that Yogs is town. CSPVG has less to confirm his claim, yogs was blocked when he tried to investigate him but this could have been purposefully to confuse town, or just a general scum role block to stop our cop getting a read. I do however tend to believe him, I think the details of his claim (name etc.) seem legitimate and it's only the timing of it that gives doubt, but I can understand his reasons for doing so.
So if CSPVG and yogs are town, unless CSPVG is naive (we have no way to know yet) that makes Lift town to due to CSPVGs read. (and also makes him entirely correct about my early ignoring of this fact)

Then we have HijacK and Robb. As I have already stated, I believe Robb's claim. While trawling the mafia wiki the only other possiblity I've found which would explain the interaction between Twilight and Robb, is if Twilight had a weak modifier and Robb is scum (this means Twilight would have died just by visiting a scum player at night).
So let's look at that scenario. If that were the case, Twilight would be town and a scum kill. But we got no flip, which would invalidate the two best theories we have on flips at the moment (no flips for scum or no flips for town kills). While we could have a more complicated system, like purely random flips (highly unlikely) or some kind of Janitor role. But as I understand it a Janitor usually cleans up their own kill, and even if we can assume they can choose to clean a fellow scum's kill that wouldn't explain either RWarehall or Twilight's lack of flip.
Which logically suggests that Robb is telling the truth or there is a more complicated and unusual role available (again, I'm discounting this as the simplest answer is usually the right one)
HijacK's night action and evidence gives strength to this story too.
Now let's look at HijacK. He could be a scum tracker / watcher / whatever who chose to reveal this role to point a finger at Robb over Twilight's death. This would suggest that Robb at least is town, and Twilight possibly too (why follow him otherwise?). He could also just be scum who knew who Twilight was visiting (if he was scum too) and used this info to fabricate a claim. But if that were the case I would imagine he would be pushing for Robb as a PGO and to lynch him, whereas this conclusion doesn't appear to have crossed HijacK's mind until Robb's claim.
So I tend to believe his claim too.

So with those assumpitions made we have me (obviously), yogs, CSPVG, Lift, Hijack & Robb all town. That's still a lot of potential scum, so let's have a look at the Night actions.

We know someone killed Darko. We can reasonably assume this was the Mafia Faction kill. That means we have one mafia who performed that action. We know (yes dedo, I know we 'know' nothing :P ) someone blocked yogs and can also assume this was probably a Mafia action. That's two mafia night actions accounted for.
I've been working under the assumption the Mafia probably have a role cop (it's role madness, it's a fairly common mafia role and a lucky scan N0 might have given them Darko's role and explain why he got hit instead of a cop)
The question is whether Twilight was that Role Cop, or whether it was someone else, and whether there are three or four mafia.

So with all those assumptions made we have 8 suspects for scum:

dedo, trent, Sage, JMich, Hyper, ddickinson, cristigale and Ix.

With there being anywhere from a 25% to a 50% chance that any given one of them is scum, depending on how many scum are left.

Of those eight I would rank them in order of least scummy to most scummy as follows:

ddickinson, JMich, Hyper, cristigale, trent, Sage, dedo and Ix.

Which right now makes Ix the best candidate, and at the risk being hypocritcal by doing the very thing I voted trent for doing:

unvote trentonIf, vote Ixamyakxim

So that's where I'm at... I doubt it will be much help to anyone, as many of you don't seem to share the same views and make the same assumptions that I have, but who knows.