Hm. Seems M8 is stealing attention from this game again.
Anyway, I find it rather worrying how many players there are in this game we have far too little data about - Cruward, Grynn/NFY (getting better there), nmillar to some extent, QA who will have to be replaced, even TwilightBard. It doesn't really feel like day two in here, does it?
Also, we're not voting! And we really should be. I admit I'm part of the problem, but that is about to change:
There's one player in this game who makes me oddly uneasy, and it won't be a surprise when I say it's Robbeasy (hey, it rhymes!). His explanation of his vote for itai was charming as always, but something about it doesn't sit right. Here are relevant bits of the vote post (#378):
Rob / Baz - for some reason the pair of you seem to be linked together at the moment. I've had a big old read through the whole thread again today , and I am leaning towards Rod being Town - if Mafia had the info he seems privy to, then they would be very strong - too strong I would say.
The only thing that really stands out - and it stands out a mile - is Baz's claim. I think we were all caught up in the argument at the time - it took someone who was late to the party (Damnation) to point out that it really is a FULL claim of DOCTOR out of nowhere! What possible leap of reasoning could ever think that was in ANY way a pro town move?? I had to reread it all again , thinking I'd missed something vital, but no, I cant for the life of me see it. The only thing that makes the remotest sense is that Baz got scared Rod knew too much about him so claimed quickly -and it's only Mafia who get scared.....
Itai.sharim - [...] Post 296 - going back to the Rod / Baz thing again, condemning Rod, then saying you think he is town , and would be happy to let him lead lynch! Of course you would - he thinks your scumbuddy Baz is town, and is blathering info all over the place...
Damnation has you rattled, and I think with good reason. What is VERY interesting is that on more than one occasion our friend Baz has complimented you on good questions - I think you are Mafia buddies. The way you both combined in the whole Rod/Baz debate just screams it out.
And here are relevant bits of #501, the explanation:
Yes - I have to hold my hand up to some flawed thinking here. Let me explain...
I have spent most of today rereading day one, looking back through all the arguments and the Rod/Baz thing especially. One thing about it stands out to my mind.
Rod couldn't possibly have the info he clearly does have, if he were Mafia. It would be too strong a role, why would the MOD inform a Mafia player of the two Town Docs? It makes no sense. So - I have to conclude that Rod is Town.
By extension, that also makes Baz Town, as him and Rod basically confirmed each other during the day. This is where my flawed thinking started, linking Itai to Baz - rereading what I put down for suspecting Itai is almost embarrassing,..which I suppose it would be, seeing as he flipped town.
Am I the only one who can't really follow the train of thought behind these two posts? Note the "This is where my flawed thinking started, linking Itai to Baz"
. There's an undocumented leap of logic somewhere in the process, which is bothering me. It's also bothering me how can anyone say Rod is town and I am scum; if Rod is town, the "town doesn't lie" rule pretty much implies I am town as well, doesn't it?
Anyway, my three greatest suspects right now?
1) Robbeasy, for using very peculiar logic to get the itai wagon going at a key moment;
2) jefequeso, because of his scummy behaviour on day one and somewhat odd behaviour on day two;
3) Damnation, for you know what, even though I'm not convinced about him, really.
Honourable mention: Rodzaju. Of course. Vote Robbeasy