Let me get it straight - you suspect me for not being suspected?
Pretty much, yeah
I don't understand what you meant there.
Care to explain?
Essentially I mean I only ever read of one mindset from you, you follow only one possibility while there might be thousands present
Did Ubivis turn to be mafia?
If not, why are you bringing this up?
Ubivis roleclaimed town doctor and got extreme amounts of flak for it - everything else is unimportant, but yes, he turned out to be the mafia roleblocker
Are you claiming nmillar pushed us into the hole, or that he stopped proding when Rod asked to drop the subject? If he stopped proding, how were we pushed into the hole?
You might wish to read that again - I also mention baz, so your question is rather strange since you focus only on me mentioning nmillar, no? Attempting to protect your partner-in-crime or something?
Irrelevant, unless you are suggesting roles were not randomly assigned.
I know this is directed at Rod, but seriously? What the hell are you trying to say here, other than you knowing who is mafia and who isn't? Rod replied to jafa who claimed nmillar was an experienced mafia player - he's experienced at the game, not at being part of the mafia, which was exactly what Rod pointed out.This means, no matter what way you cut it, that nmillar is experienced at the game, but is a newbie at being mafia. The fact that you bring up the question whether the roles are randomly assigned or not and that Rod's post is irrelevant seems to me that you know more of the setup than us - such as who is mafia and who isn't?
As for the phrasing at post 39 by nmillar - quoting before saying something usually explains your reasoning, and post 39 quoted the flavor. Moreover, nmillar is consistent with his reasoning a week after it was first brought up (post 90, answer to baz in particular). All in all, it seems as a weak argument against nmillar.
Let me just quote post 90 for you,
No, just common sense based on the information provided in the first post.
Said in response to baz questioning a theory nmillar suggested in post 86, which is NOT post 39. Please note that we're dealing with how he phrased post 39 - this has been elaborated upon and discussed between your post and my wall of text. Had post 86 been his original post on the whole "more mafia factions than 1", there would be no issue - we're discussing his statement, which was made as though he considered there being multiple mafia factions as fact, not as a possibility (Which to anyone who do not know the setup is all the conclusion we can arrive at - it being possible, but not certain - at least until more information is delivered)
Actually, Damnation has now suppresed QuadrAlien as my top suspect for causing commotion and confusion in town. Not voting yet, as I want to wait for the response.
Always happy to help, I suppose :p