As the kids say these days: Holy sophism, Batman!
Oh, but the same applies to Damnation right?
Yes, the exact same applies to Damnation.
It would be stupid for me to say "Guys, I'm just vanilla - I'll hammer!". It would be stupid for Damnation to say "Guys, I'm just vanilla - I'll hammer!"
It would not be stupid for me to hammer, if the majority of the players want me to, because they think I'm a likely scum suspect. It would not be stupid for Damnation to hammer, if the majority of the players want him to, because they think him a likely scum suspect.
So your point is that if damnation refuses he is scum, but you not doing it means your town?
My not doing what?
And my point has nothing to do with Damnation. My point is that if the designated hammerer, as chosen by the town, refuses to hammer, they should be lynched instead.
So what your actually saying is one of two things: You believe Damnation (who have been confirmed by another source) to be a more likely scum, than you who are only claimed by yourself.
That's only one thing.
And you're trying to trick me into saying something I haven't. I have not argued that Damnation should hammer, as I already told you in our last little chat
And the proof we should accept that for is that you know your town hence don't want to hammer.
I doubt anyone wants
to hammer a claimed a bomb.
Actually in my opinion offering to be hammer of one suspected as scum, knowing that doing so will kill you is more townish.
And in my opinion, offering to hammer would be completely idiotic. Surely you see the difference between offering to hammer, and being chosen by the town to hammer, because the town think you are a likely scum suspect.
Did I ever say I wasn't? If the majority deem me a likely scum suspect, I have no problem hammering SPF. But saying "Guys, I'm only vanilla, so I can hammer!" would be downright stupid.
You did however quite willingly accept that argument from Baz without commenting on it.
Baz has quite clearly stated that he is suspicious of Damnation, so he's not suggesting for him to hammer only because he is a claimed vanilla.
However, the point that placing a bomb on a mafia would be a strange decision by the mod, a point first brought up by SPF, does hold some value. So I might have to rethink my stance on that.
@nmillar: You still haven't answered my question on whether or not your role name is "vanilla townie".
Also looking forward to hearing Baz' big idea.