When I said that Angelo should not be revealed I was thinking about cop.
Cop is a role that is traditionally kept secret.
The qualifier does reduce the need for this, but I was not thinking about that at the time.
It is not the qualifier that only makes sense in a multi-mafia setup.
It is a scum cop that only makes sense in a multi-mafia setup.
I have been cagey about revealing information as it is constantly being said that role info should not be revealed lightly.
Therefore, unless things change drastically, I will not mention the other 2 I know of.
Then I can't help wonder, if you yourself state that the role only makes sense in a multi mafia set up, hence assuming that that role is owned by a scum, why would it not benefit town to know it? If you knew that it was a town role I can understand holding something back, but not if its a scum. Getting the info out that there is a risk of a scum cop can only be useful. Of course all assuming that what you say is true.
And I am somewhat assuming that you didn't think of this while first mentioning this, as nmillar was the one who brought up multi-mafia at the first time, so wouldn't a better reason be that you didn't want to reveal a cop, then learned about a possible multi-mafia and then decided it could be a mafia role. But interestingly enough, thats not your reason. (Or that might have been what you said in some cryptic way). I understand it as saying that you suspected it to be a scum cop even before considering the qualifier (which you had from the beginning as well). And you mentioned earlier in the game that it was the flavor you received that made you suspect one of the roles as a scum. Was that flavor the start-up game flavor or was it the pm flavor, which I understood to be?