Anyhow, more important stuff. I find Orryyrro's return quite interesting. I mean, day 1 he shows more activity than he would normally, on the second day, he almost disappears, then reappears with a vote for the most obvious target (Rodzaju) with almost no explanation whatsoever. QuadrAlien is extremely silent so far, cruward is not saying much either (Likely due to his newbieness), and then there are possibly other lurkers I have forgotten all about.
Twilight hasn't said much either today.
A few people are saying chances are Rod is Town - the only thing that gives you this 'certainty' is the fact of Rod having so much 'info' that he couldn't possibly be Mafia, as the role would be too strong.
The only 'info' we know for certain is taken entirely at the behest of another player - Baz. All else could be completely made up, for all we know. Far-fetched?? Not nearly as far-fetched as his bizarre claim!
What do we do ? Our only and prime priority is gathering confirmed information. Everything else is WIFOM - there will ALWAYS be an argument for and against, as you have players with opposing views.
The best way of confirming what we have so far is to lynch Rod. Why?
If he is Town -
Baz is exonerated - we have a definite paranoid Doctor with us. He becomes a powerful weapon for Town. Other players , in their defence or otherwise of Rod can be judged. Meh, if he flips town no doubt I will come under pressure, but it's not about single players - its about a Town win! It's all about going with the information we have and testing it, and this is the best way to do that.
If he is Mafia -
Baz has to look suspect. Ditto Jefequeso, who has continually stated his belief they are town.
Don't get me wrong here - I think Rod is scum, but I'm by no means 100% certain. But taking the bigger view, name me one other player that would yield up the information that would best serve town, if they were lynched. If Rod flips town no doubt I will come under suspicion, but I'm willing to accept that as I see no other option this day that gives us anywhere near the information lynching Rod would do.
Yes, I'm pushing it, and push it I will continue to do. Its the most logical and best step we can make as town - I cant see anything else happening today to change that view. Until this is cleared up I think anything else that happens today will be a massive WIFOM discussion and ultimately lead nowhere.
Vote remains on Rod