You know what's really weird? That nmillar case Damnation was so eager to push (you have to hand it to Damn, though, he really knows how to take the stage by storm).
Look, I'll go meta now. Nmillar is a veteran on these forums, and a lot of us have played with him before. So we all know that he has this habit of jumping at conclusions at an alarming rate. That post of his? That's pure 100% nmillar, through and through. Taking a small thing and BAM! forming a conclusion. (Just to be sure: I'm not making fun of him; he's repeatedly shown he's willing to let go of these conclusions just as quickly. It's just what he does, and he's actually fairly successful with it.) And Damnation really ought to know that, which is what makes his insistence on this being a case against nmillar so puzzling. Also, calling it a "slip"? Nonsensical. You'd have to be an idiot to post something like this accidentally. I'm not ruling out the possibility that nmillar is scum, and did it deliberately, but honestly, a "slip"?
Another thing I don't quite like about Damn's wild accusations was that while he did call Rod's play "bad moves", or something like that, all his subsequent comments on it paint the picture in such a way that Rod is basically a victim of nmillar and me forcing him to cough up the information. Honestly, I have no idea how did he get to that. All I see in my posts at the time is "what the fuck are you doing here, Rod?" (I'm paraphrasing here). Not "this is interesting, now go on or I'll kill you, Rod!"
Also, Joe? You're in hyper mode again. Dial it down a bit, please.
First of all, I am only pushing my case against nmillar because people keep pushing me about it. Which is fine, but pushing me for pushing back? Well, sure, why not :D
Anyhow, it's 100% nmillar, yes, and let's metadance about this, baz. You say that I should have learnt nmillar's playstyle by now, I have, and I always see him as scummy because of his random statements when they have absolutely no argumentation, or no clear one anyhow. If you have the gall to question whether I know nmillar's playstyle, do you not think it behooves you to know mine? I've been around a while too, you know, my playstyle doesn't deviate much from game to game (And it only deviates when happenings in the game require it to)
And you know what's funny? You saying I make wild accusations - all my accusations have been argumented and backed up. Plus, I have only accused three people - itai, nmillar and Joe, and I am still accusing all three.
And the point about me painting Rod a victim - you're right, I am, and it's a very bad decision if he's mafia, I know. But I do nonetheless for I see him as a victim in that situation - you DID push him, and I can perfectly understand why you cannot see that. You were on the other end of the conversation, you thought you were screaming "what the fuck are you doing here, Rod?" as you say so yourself though it was evident Rod did not see it the same way, he thought you were pushing him for information, and thus, your methods did result in you pushing him. He even mentioned himself he only outed your role name as his own way of saying "This isn't help!" - had you NOT inquired so much about his information, or outright said "Stop, this isn't helping!" I strongly doubt it would have ended up the way it did.