OK, having gone through my notes, my suspicion of you IS based mainly (but NOT entirely) round what looks like a very peculiar relationship with Muttly.
The 2 of you NEVER agree on ANYTHING.
He keeps voting you & then very soon afterwards unvoting.
In fact, after RVS (and excluding Orry & very recently me) he has never voted for anyone except you.
This leads me to believe that, rather than "I think you are scum", his votes were part of a pattern of what could easily be coded communication.
You vote Orry
#281 Muttly votes you.
#284 Primal explains suspicion of Orry as Rule 9 not broken.
#285 Muttly unvotes Primal, but doesn’t vote anyone else.
#359 You say that the game might be over by morning...
As this is impossible, given that night actions (following the day 1 example) took more than 24 hours, are you telling your scumbuddy to hurry up the lynch?
Muttly doesn’t post, so you add a bit more pressure in #372
#377 Muttly appears.
This is where he makes his amazing “I believe Orry, but am happy to lynch him anyway” comment.
The ONLY way that this makes any sense at all is if it some kind of coded message for someone.
He votes you again & casts the unfounded suspicion that you vote for the flavour of the day.
#401 you state that you are suspicous of me, but can’t explain why.
#407 Muttly unvotes you & again does not vote anyone else.
#416 Muttly names you as one of his 2 most suspicous, but does not add a vote.
#419 he votes Orry (L-1)
#463 (First post of day 4) you raise the possibility of mafia role cop.
#478 Muttly poo – poos this idea & suggests the mafia are experienced players.
Pretty transparent attempt to say “It can’t be me, I’m not experienced enough”.
I raise my 2-1 mafia theory #518, 520, 522, 532, 536
#537 & 538 you & Muttly disagree again.
#585 / 586 And again
#633 brings Muttly’s shepherd comment that turns out (according to 654) to be a little dig at a conversation you were in.
#657 – 664 The FIRST TIME you and Muttly agree on ANYTHING & it’s the fact that I look suspicious.
Because of my scumtheory, possibly.
#684 Muttly says that I’m not the most suspicous, but he can get support for a lynch.
Perhaps he is accepting the instruction that he ignored back in #401?
There are also some issues that Don't involve Muttly though:
#316 Joe expresses displeasure in response to queries about the game setup.
#318 you say “The mod is a dick”
#346 you say it is too early to comment on the setup until we know whether Orry is telling the truth.
So either 318 was an attempt to curry favour with those moaning about the setup, or you realised you had slipped up (as mafia, you knew Orry would flip town & thus was likely telling the truth.) & were now backtracking to cover this.
#490 you bring up not defending newbies anymore.
#493 you backtrack on this “it wasn’t about this game...”
Also in #346 you say that the only confirmed weird thing is Xyem’s post restriction.
How was this confirmed?