Why do I believe him? Because the whole setup does feel fairly convoluted, it seems designed to make us argue this, not believe our cop at all. I also believe him because, the complicated mess of it is quite frankly, too complicated for me to even consider something a Mafia would throw out at this stage. All the Mafia have knowledge of is Xyem's post restrictions, and would probably be weary of claiming a power role without having a clue what Xyem's is.
If we had a tracker or role cop then we might have a better idea, And if the mafia has a roleblocker, wouldn't that person be stuck blocking Orry the whole time too? So the mafia has a role that's tied to Orry to keep him 'useless'.
On the other hand, if Orryyrro was Mafia, then pointing out a townie is a good way to get us to use another lynch to confirm...which is fairly dangerous. The reality is that if Orryyrro flips Mafia, then Baz has to be lynched or dealt with somehow, he'd be too much of a liablity otherwise.
But, that's not what's bothering me right now...
Xyem claimed that his restriction isn't useful at all, suggesting that he may have had a one-use ability that he had to keep posting in such a way so he could use it. Mods don't tend to just hand those out to Vanilla Townies.
Pazzer always lurks like that though for the most part, but that definitely means that he should not be allowed to reach LyLo (Lynch or Lose) at all. A townie that lurks that much has a very high chance of being a game losing mislynch.
Muttly being quiet at this stage is a bit odd, I admit, but we still have a ton of time before the deadline (Methinks this one is livable unless something really stupid happens)
I'll dig through more later, gotta head out for a bit.