Just testing (since I'm unable to preview)

http://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_forum_mafia_14_the_curse_of_the_seth_beast/post1784

thank you for the tip....I knew there had to be a better way

http://www.gog.com/forum/general/gog_forum_mafia_14_the_curse_of_the_seth_beast/post1783

Excercise is bad.

You should stop.

One more suggestion, use
(url=http)text(/url) so you get something like this
Feel free to hit reply to see the whole post code.

Just noticed I got the name wrong so for correction: flubbucket

Another note: APF as far as I am aware you already voted and have yet to unvote before voting again.. So are you multivoting :P

JMich: The holes that the whole plan hinges on Damnation and a doctor to survive.

If scum have one who can hit through protection or some way to acquire it (coins?) then he is death, and can't investigate anyone.

If there isn't a doctor: Damnation won't be protected and likely die

If Damnation is indeed town (Yes I trust he is, but we never know anything 100%) so if he isn't were putting too much trust in one player (minor point)

If there is a doctor, scum will likely target someone else than Damnation since they would know he would be protected, as such increasing the risk that a they either hit the doctor or someone else with a steadily decreasing amount of people to pick from to night kill.. and without a lynch they don' have any risk unless found by damnation.

So they could just do: Kill a townie, damnation investigates, he either finds or doesn't find one, in the case of none then we don't lynch - mafia kills another person, damnation does the same thing and so forth. However as town population decreases the potential doctor would likely be hit and unless mafia was already dead there they would kill damnation, leaving us with two dead powerroles and whomever they also killed.
Or they'll just block him every night assuming they have the a blocker, thus making no lynch even worse.
As such the plan would depend on luck.

Luck that we're correct to assume a doctor based on a claim by Telika whom I personally have as scum
Luck that Damnation hits a scum with his investigation (better chance here if our picks are good).

No I believe that we should use the lynch as the weapon it is.

Joe: The reason I addressed you and JMich is simple not because I want you to fill guiltily for making me suspect you, but because I wanted a response to the reasons I posted to suspect you.

I'm sorry but even this isn't sufficient. Without entering in the details, I am not in position to assume that we necessarily have a proper doctor.

Heh, well then just luck if we even have a doctor

Finally got done with the whole exam thing. I'll catch up as fast as I can

flubbucket = fail

That's some fairly odd quirk, posting doubt about cop claim, all that...

Are you saying it's odd to doubt Damnation's claim? Why's that? I see good reason to doubt his claim, as well as good reason to believe it.


Robbeasy where did you go?

Okay I'm ready to lynch SirPrimalform on the grounds that on the face of it he's one of the only ones left who could be mafia. (on the grounds that he hasn't claimed in any way). AS such here we go are you ready? vote SirPrimalform. Ho hum.

I was a tad sarcastic (hey, FOLLOW THE DISCUSSION !).

Im here Joe! At the office again today so posting is sparse...

Not seen a deal to change my opinions - except to perhaps push A_F_P slightly more Town, and SirPrimalForm can be added to my scum list, along with Joe

Scumlist -

Telika
Pazzer/Flubbucket
SirPrimalForm
JoeSapphire

Neutral -

A_F_P
Jmich

Townlist -

Red_Baron
Damnation
Rodzaju
Me!
TwilightBard


Although my vote is on Telika, its not set in stone. He HAS been posting a lot more town-like recently. Flubbucket is difficult - Pazzer was just a lurkin', so no info on him apart from vote avoidance / participation.

A_F_P gets town points for the dream thing. Joe just keeps swinging back and forth.

Damnations Claim - no-one has counter claimed, or breadcrumbed anything (although I'm the worlds worst at finding those) to make me doubt his claim yet. I would have thought someone would have said something to challenge it if they had the info, so have to believe he is Cop for now.

Lol! I think in the votecount before last, NFY auto removed my vote since pazzer was replaced :)

*whoops*

Excuse this poor Knight, he is not used to the position of GOGfather.

Hmm, there seems to be a genuine bandwagon forming on me now. Pretty sure Telika is town, but the two others (that I am aware of) are straight off my scum list. AFP has been at the top of it for what seems like forever and Joe has been sitting at the bottom of it recently.

All I can say to Joe is that he must have missed something in his process of elimination. Obviously everyone who has claimed is telling the truth and therefore I must be scum. Interesting reasoning considering you haven't claimed yet Joe...

Anyway, I have no intention of claiming unless a majority asks me to or if I get to L-2. If I get speed lynched or something, I think Telika is town and that AFP is scum. Those are the reads I'm fairly certain of.