So since I started it: Damnation in his former form made the list due to the odd playstyle and the habit of proclaiming town alignments based on highly shaky arguments, some which makes no sense at all. Seemed to be a ploy to appear good, and as such I have seen it (a ploy).
He gets a 5/10 scum score.
Damnation was only on the suspect list due to his former souls playstyle.
Do replacements change roles as well? Or do they keep their previous role? I was under the assumption that they kept the previous one, which means that if N0x0ss read like a scum to you, Damnation is a scum as well. Please correct me if I'm wrong, since this is a big part of the reason I am voting for you after all.
I'm fairly sure I have n0x0ss' role. So if n0x0ss pinged your scumdar, I should as well. Hey, n0x0ss even pinged my scumdar...
I'll just let you people know who I find the most scum:
A_Future_Pilot - either a newbie who has taken no interest in researching the game, or a he's scum. Many others have argued the same points I hold - in mostly his readiness to join Damuna in her desire to lynch Robbeasy, and he's seeming excessive damage control attempts.
nmillar - as I have mentioned, he plays a tad too familiarly with his style in mafia 9, where he turned out to be mafia. It's early in the game though, so I have no wish to really push him right now. He has performed exceedingly scummy behaviour when town before.
Damuna/Red_Baron - Damuna should come as no direct surprise I hope. She wanted to get out of RVS fast, and did so by attempting to pull at the structure of the game, slightly fishing for knowledge from other players. Now, she's not in the game anymore, and I cannot expect Red_Baron to argue for her actions, I will still hold her actions as indication that something might be off with Red_Baron. RB himself though... He argued he saw me as scum because of n0x0ss actions - were I to extend the same courtesey, I would see him hang right now :p He, himself, however, beat around the bush like there's no freaking tomorrow. Seriously, take any of his posts, read them, then strip away 90% of the sentences, keeping with the middle ones or one or two of the finishing lines and BAM, his entire point in far less the space. Ergo, his posts can only be made to confuse people.
That goes to many others though - if you write up a wall of text, read through it yourself at least twice first and see if you cannot make your point any shorter. Far too many of you beat around the bush for no fucking reason.
Also, it's day 1, the game has barely started, town knows shit, and some of you expect to get grand cases against each other already - that's quite interesting, I must say. Especially when you consider how Mafia 11 started out...